//ck/
Redpill me on nitrided carbon steel. Should I replace my old non-stick pan with one?
Showing all 91 replies.
>>
you should replace your old non stick with literally anything else
>>
>>22049643
If you're serious about cooking, you should be YSZ coating your pans
>>
>>22049661
YSZeez Nuts faggot
>>
>>22049662
>worse
explain or stfu
>>
>>22049643
no. go with cast iron. it will last the rest of your life.
>>
and cost 1/3rd of this new fangled pan gadget. they boast about how it weighs half the cast iron of same diameter but thats not a good thing for many reasons.
>>
>>22049643
>oven-safe to 450
There be teflon in that thar pan.
>>
>>22049977
its strange it says that because on websites they say these pans are good up to 1000F, grills, campfires etc.
>>
>>22049977
You can just ask AI. It's a great tool for that if you adjust your settings to only get answers from reputable sources like universities. The short answer is no. The long answer is: there's a whole lot of PFAS which are currently being used to weasel out of the health disaster, but it's not known how safe they are.
>>
>>22049987
>just ask AI.
no
>>
>>22049987
>reputable sources
>like universities
pffhahah
>>
>>22049651
Why? NTA but I thought non stick pans was fine if you followed the directions like only using silicone cooking utensils, not heating it too hot, keeping it scatch free, etc.
>>
>>22049876
No
>>
>>22050244
Modern non stick is fine if you don't do any of these and replace it every two years or something.
>>
>>22049977
This kek. Misen lied to their customers to get more people buying
>>
>>22050334
>>22050244
Why choose something you know you'll have to replace, AND has a risk of poisoning you..?
I've had my cast iron for 10yrs now, stainless steel for like 8 I think. Definitely precovid at least.
>>
>>22050352
Convenience. I also have a glass top range and cast iron scratches it so I can only use my cast iron in the oven. Stainless steel is more inconvenient than a non stick. And I think the poisoning rumors of teflon are overblown if you're properly caring for a teflon pan like I do.
>>
>>22050244
>>22050334
Its not. They have been saying, “the new nonstick is safe” for like 75 years running. Last 20 years, it’s been a lot of
“This one isn’t teflon, it’s CERAMIC nonstick”
“This isn’t teflon, it’s DIAMONDS nonstick”
“This is STAINLESS STEEL nonstick, no teflon!”
And every single one is teflon. They get around it by making some minor change to the DuPont Teflon formula and call it a whole new thing. But it’s all the same.

not to mention, why even? Just learn how to cook on a regular pan and nothing will ever stick again.
>>
>>22050399
Enjoy your parkinson’s. At least you didn’t get any scratches on your gay stove kwab
>>
what's more terminally online schizo: seed oil hysteria or teflon hysteria?
>>
>>22050409
sanctimonious faggot
>>
I like mine. It's not coated, you can use metal utensils with it
>>
I just use ceramic for everything because it's naturally non-stick, easy to clean and impossible to chip or scrape unless you are cooking with a battleaxe
>but it's heavy!
That's a good thing, more lifting = more gains
>>
>>22050352
>Why choose something you know you'll have to replace
Because typical non stick pan is pretty universal. If you just cook something casually every now and then then non stick is the closest you can get to one pan for everything. If you are more knowledge and don't mind some maintenance then sure, you can get stainless steel for sauces and acidic food, carbon steel for stir fry, cast iron for everything else, but an average person doesn't need that. They just need to do scrambled eggs and bolognese and a basic non stick is fine for it.

>>22050408
>And every single one is teflon.
If a seller is lying to you then that's some ground for suing.

>regular pan
No such thing. There are various pans suitable suitable for various ranges of tasks.
>>
>>22050334
>replace it every two years or something.
LOL
>>
>>22050432
he's right though
>>
File: pants.gif (131.8 KB)
131.8 KB
>>22050509
>Because typical non stick pan is pretty universal. If you just cook something casually every now and then then non stick is the closest you can get to one pan for everything. If you are more knowledge and don't mind some maintenance then sure, you can get stainless steel for sauces and acidic food, carbon steel for stir fry, cast iron for everything else, but an average person doesn't need that. They just need to do scrambled eggs and bolognese and a basic non stick is fine for it.
Ok, i'm happy for you, or sorry that happened.
>>
>>22050582
not really, statistical studies are nearly always overinterpreted nonsense
>>
>>22050270
then pay $120 for a new fangled thing that isn't as good. your choice.
>>
>>22050855
Cast iron is a meme and you suck at cooking
>>
>>22050856
totally worthless opinion with a truth value of zero. go buy your expensive meme pan if it will make you feel better.
>>
>>22050856
>Cast iron cookware, in use for hundreds of years, is the meme
>but not my expensive fancy new fangled pan. oh no, thats the real deal
ok sweaty
>>
>>22050244


I just don’t Cook in fuckin yucky synthetic plastic
>>
>>22050399


Kek shoulda just got a normal coil stove
>>
>>22051270
they are such a meme
>>
>>22051264
>synthetic plastic
Kek.
Mong.
>>
>>22051284


Induction stoves too


They work well, but they get scratched immediately and look ugly as fuck right


>>22051287


If I’m Cooking in fuckin plastic, you KNOW it’s gotta be 100% Natural Polymers
>>
>>22051294
i like cast iron pans on a cast iron cooker and cast iron wood stove. it should all last a good long time and keep looking better with age
>>
File: IMG_0410.jpg (194.6 KB)
194.6 KB
>>22051300


“Based” 100% Natural Polymer enjoyer
>>
>>22051305
i like the truth of it even if running to chatbots for your answers is really uncool.
>>
File: steel.jpg (24.8 KB)
24.8 KB
>cast iron r*dditors
the "seasoning" on cast iron cookware is polymerized oil which is a carcinogen that goes into your food every time you cook and into your lungs when you're burning the oil in your home
you're just trading one poison for another if you switch from teflon to cast iron
stainless steel is all you need
>>
File: IMG_0345.jpg (107.8 KB)
107.8 KB
>>22051306


It’s just the easiest way to convey said Truth


Don’t need to link a whole dissertation to say that Cast Iron is Superiore due to its 100% Natural Polymers
>>
File: IMG_0411.jpg (384.2 KB)
384.2 KB
>>22051313


That isn’t True at all THOUGH
>>
>>22051318
stop spamming the board with ai slop you worthless fucking idiot
>>
File: IMG_0250.jpg (2.5 MB)
2.5 MB
>>22051322


Stop spamming the board with disingenuous falsities you worthless fucking idiot
>>
>>22051313
>cast iron is a meme
>>cast iron r*dditors
are people really this fucked in the head? its THEM who have been fooled by memes and reddit because thats as wide as their frame of reference goes.
>>
>>22050408
This.
I have stainless and CI. I know how to properly use both. Nothing sticks to them. They're all at least 15 years old, the CI is significantly older. They won't ever poison me. They won't ever need to be replaced. I could easily beat a nonstickfag to death with one and wouldn't even worry when his eyebrow piercing scraped the metal.
>>
>>22049643
you should buy what the pros use. cases of cheap shit from restaurant supply stores. why pay $150 for one pan when you can get 12 for the same price? bonus you can just throw it out if you fuck it up.
>>
>>22049685
Heh got em
>>
>>22050429
Shouldn't you be on /b/ posting child porn or something right now?
>>
>>22051294
>Induction stoves too
>They work well, but they get scratched immediately and look ugly as fuck right
What? I've used the same induction stove for over 15 years and it's not scratched.
>>
>>22052647
i'd like to see if thats true. for science.
>>
>>22049643
If you're not using tungsten carbide pans for your eggs ur basically retarded
>>
>>22052668


Do you use Cast Iron on it?
>>
>>22050244
non stick pans all have an expiration date, even if you treat them properly.
>>
>>22051318
can someone explain to me where this "THOUGH" meme came from and why im supposed to like it?
>>
>>22052803
i prefer the diamond tipped pans. much tougher
>>
>>22049643
carbon steel is what they use in pro kitchens
>>
>>22052848
get a load of this faggot

if ur not using Yttrium MOF coated pans ur living in abject poverty and will NEVER be a skilled cuck like Babish
>>
>>22050466
I love my ceramic. But it did get a slight crack from a fork.
>>
>>22053013
>>22050466
>natural ceramic nonstick :-D
You were fooled. Its a steel pan with a ceramic coating, with teflon on the coating. They call it “ceramic nonstick” because they know that you know ceramic isn’t a plastic and doesn’t leach.
Same deal with “parchment paper” its rubber coated but if they call it parchment paper people think its made from papyrus or something.
>>
>>22052828
Ending a post with THOUGH was a /qa/ meme.
It was an interesting time we had.
>>
>>22053147
>It was an interesting time we had.
getting psyopped by feds and arrested?
>>
>>22052809
Yes, until I grew up and moved to carbon steel.
>>
>>22052989
>babish
Didn't that fool get raped in a psyche ward and then post about it on reddit?
>>
>>22051313
If dose makes the poison cast iron is still better because it’s not so concentrated it kills birds
>>
>>22050399
> cast iron scratches it
How clumsy are you? I also have a glasstop and have never scratched the surface.
>>
File: IMG_7877.jpg (618.3 KB)
618.3 KB
>>22050509
That doesn’t answer my question at all. It wears out faster regardless.
That’s like an argument for paper plates lol nonsensical and uneconomical
>>
>>22052639
Another benefit of CI is definitely home defense
>>
What about seasoning nonstick pans?
>>
>>22051258
Cast iron is not non stick
>>
>>22054005
>Didn't that fool get raped in a psyche ward and then post about it on reddit?
Yeah, can't find the link though.
>>
>>22054023
>That doesn’t answer my question at all.
You asked why choose teflon. I told you why people choose teflon, because it is universal. It's convenient.
>>
>>22054085
it is if you're not a retard
>>
>>22050408
Greenpan thermolon is a true inorganic ceramic, of course it doesn't last as long. Some of the ILAG coatings are Siloxane based, if you prefer silicone over teflon plastic in your food.

https://www.ilag-group.com/en/ceramic-non-stick-coating/
>not to mention, why even? Just learn how to cook on a regular pan and nothing will ever stick again.
It's nice to be able to just throw frozen fish in a cold pan and still have it work out fine.
>>
>>22054131
> more universal
What does that even mean
> more convenient
How is it more convenient when it needs replacing more often?
Again
Paper plate-ass reasoning
>>
>>22049987
>You can just ask AI.
Not even gonna bother reading the rest of your shit. Grow a brain please
>>
>>22054274
>What does that even mean
It means it covers the widest range of use cases a typical casual person would need a pan for.

>How is it more convenient when it needs replacing more often?
Most people who only cook occasionally can afford to and would rather replace teflon every few years than buy multiple different pans, some of which require extra maintenance, care and knowledge.
>>
File: IMG_7886.jpg (77.3 KB)
77.3 KB
>>22054401
Frankly, there are just some things i will never understand why people do them
>>
>>22049643
it's about as nonstick as cast iron so no
>>
>>22053434
I have no fucking idea what you're rambling about.
>>
File: 1771562815087911.jpg (60.0 KB)
60.0 KB
>>22049643
I remember Hop said it's more rust resistant than the magnesium/anodised milspec shit but I'm a nogunz fag so don't listen to me.
>>
>>22054085
100% a skill issue.
>>
>>22049643
All of the crankshafts I install into engines are nitrided steel. They hold up very well over long years of hard use. I do see scratches when metal contamination causes bits to get stuck between the bearings and journals, so I suppose a regrind might be required if you aren't checking your oil filters properly. As for a cooking utensil, I dont know dick about shit when it comes to nitrided steel pans. I just use CI and an Our Place nonstick I was gifted a few years ago. Reading this thread didnt convince me to go out and buy a Nitrided Steel pan, since it is mostly people arguing about polymers and CI rather than discussing OP's topic.
>>
>>22055325
OPs pan just sounds like yet another gimmick that costs 3x what a decent CI does for no real difference.
>>
>>22055329
Wonderful. (More) marketing gimmicks.
>>
>>22055334
the cookware market certainly has more than its fair share.
>>
>>22049643 (OP)
carbon steels are my favorites. More mass and heat retention than stainless steel, less of a bitch to maintain than cast iron. It's the best of both worlds imo.
I wouldn't get one from Misen though. The endless yootoobe sponsorship shilling is already a redflag in itself, but the fact it's only oven-safe up to 450 makes no fucking sense, like >>22049977 said there's probably teflon or other crap coating on it.
>>
>>22055534
DeBuyer has powder coating on their pans with non stainless handles. Aren't oven safe on high temp either.
>>
>>22055558
On their non stainless handles I meant, not the pans obviously.
>>
I got one of these but the nitriding doesn't seem to be that good. I was expecting it to be like the bolt on my ar-15 where it's slick as hell and nothing will stick to it, but after using it for a while it doesn't seem to be that much better than my allclad. also the rivets clearly aren't treated because they had some shit flake off of them and now they rust if I don't keep them oiled.

Reply to Thread #22049643


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)