>widely considered
By who? Salty Disneyfags?

File: which-thomas-surprised-shocked-faces-is-your-favourite-v0-lsjvuo2kb97c1.jpg (6 KB)

6 KB JPG

>>153260803

File: Screenshot From 2026-04-16 21-14-35.png (537.4 KB)

537.4 KB PNG

the east coast creatures look funny and the animationa are expressive for all of them.

>>153261071
>In his 1983 essay “1,112 and Counting,” gay activist Larry Kramer accused then-New York mayor Ed Koch of allowing gay men to die of a disease that had recently been dubbed Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, writing that he had “not allow[ed] himself to be perceived by the non-gay world as visibly helping us.” (That Koch was less-than-forthcoming about his own sexuality adds another layer to the story.) That same year, Jimmy Picker made this astoundingly tone-deaf Claymation short wherein Koch (voiced by an impressionist) improvises his own version of Kander & Ebb’s hit song “New York, New York.” By the time Picker won his Oscar, at least 200 more gay men had died from AIDS-related illnesses.
https://www.vulture.com/article/best-oscar-winner-for-animated-shorts-ranked.html

>>153260803
It's pretty funny, and all the celebrity caricatures are amusing. Claymation is cool, too.

>>153263044
So basically people reading/projecting a lot of stuff onto it that isn't there?

>>153261071
Reddit hated it too: it’s near the bottom on their list.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Oscars/comments/1sniuvn/every_oscar_winning_animated_short_film_ranked/

>>153263735
>Reddit hated it too
Well then I feel vindicated in thinking it was funny and charming

>>153263044
>allowing gay men to die of a disease that had recently been dubbed Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
It's hilarious to me how faggots always talk about AIDS like it's something that couldn't have been prevented if they didn't have anonymous sex with hundreds of strangers.

>>153264282
Hindsight is 20/20, nobody knew what the fuck was going in in 1983. But yeah, hygiene is important, people!

File: 1540169331347.png (292.5 KB)

292.5 KB PNG

>>153260803
So if this is the worst, how bad was the competition that year?

>>153264340
It beat Mickey’s Christmas Carol, and this other short…
https://youtube.com/watch?v=tFg2EdYwvEc

>>153264823
That was really good, too. Its' waaay more Oscar-baity than Sundae is, so I guess it's a little surprising this didn't win over that, but then again, the Oscar voters don't always reward the blatant Oscar-bait stuff.

>>153262175
>the east coast creatures look funny
That's a silly way of saying this is clearly very JEWISH.

>>153263735
this is literally one random person you moron
>2020s school shooter dramabait in the top ten
>one of Disney's best shorts Der Fuehrer's Face below their worst It's Tough to Be a Bird
>Bao above Geri's Game
>Bao above every other Pixar short
>John Hubley's Moonbird dead fucking last
with shit taste too btw
the only person who's opinions on the oscar-nominated shorts you should listen to is ME

File: homer smile.jpg (32.3 KB)

32.3 KB JPG

>>153260803
Mmm... Sundae...

>>153265391
Ok, so how would you rank those shorts?

>>153263044
I literally do not care about faggots killing themselves because they can't resist getting fucked by a thousand men per year

>>153265818
The problem is it spread from the dirty faggots to the non-dirty faggots and the bisexuals and from there to non-faggot men and women. Diseases don't confine themselves to groups you don't like.

Good hygiene should be everybody's concern. That shit could just as easily have popped up among hetero swingers of the 70s as among the gays, they just got unlucky.

>>153260803
It's pretty bad, people are arguing about semantics on the thread but if you just sit down and watch it it's fucking dreadful.

>>153265893
It's no worse than the other nominees