Thread #50840433
File: image.jpg (52.7 KB)
52.7 KB JPG
Would the Touhou canon benefit from a new director? Should ZUN finally break his status quo mantra?
84 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 132_s.jpg (64.8 KB)
64.8 KB JPG
>>50840433
Xitter thread aside. It's more like the whole status quo is holding the series back. ZUN really loves his settings, and he usually likes simple characters like pic rel or fairies, which is why the fairy mangas are the best out there.
>>
File: IMG_1089.png (55.5 KB)
55.5 KB PNG
>>50840433
Holding it back in regards to what? The gameplay? The danmaku patterns? The stage designs? Graphics? Music? Or is this just a troon storyfag gripe that Zun isn't writing some epic drama story with deep esoteric themes, and "letting his setting's and character's potential go to waste"? If it's the latter, then fuck off. Touhou doesn't need a story beyond telling the player why he should clear the game.
>>50840769
Status quo isn't holding anything back. As long as each game tells us a story with six bosses causing an incident, there doesn't need to be anything bigger. Arguments like this annoy me, because they seem to always come from secondaries and nogames people, who don't even play the games. It's like how people kept shitting on Megaman 4-7 despite not even playing them, because "the story was stupid". The manga only really exists to supplement the games and make the world more vibrant. Only FDS has been living a life of its own. And arguably Touhou has been becoming more story-heavy over the years. Just compare the amount and style of dialogue before and now.
>>
>>
File: 1775657398962245.jpg (33.9 KB)
33.9 KB JPG
>>50840804
I was talking about the print works, which have gotten mid over time.
The games are usually self-contained enough to not care about their lore. I just really need more Misumaru desu.
>The manga only really exists to supplement the games and make the world more vibrant. Only FDS has been living a life of its own.
Touhou Literature has always been its own thing since Eastern and Little Nature Deity. They were more than just glorified loredumps.
Even with the actual supplemental materials like Cage in Lunatic Runagate, the games hardly acknowledged it due to its simplistic nature. It's why no one gives a shit about them unless you're either a lorefag or just someone who likes to read.
>And arguably Touhou has been becoming more story-heavy over the years. Just compare the amount and style of dialogue before and now.
Yeah, I miss when it was more fun.
>>
>>
Kuso Xitter troon thread.
>>50840804
This anon nailed it.
/thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1000009993.png (1.9 MB)
1.9 MB PNG
>>50840433
ZUN's creativity (and likely passion) for the series has been waning for a long time now. I don't think he should be ousted, but it's time for him to reconsider being a solo dev. There are legions of very talented and creative people who would sell their kidneys to work with ZUN. The creative input of these people (who are first and foremost fans) would be nothing but a boon to both Touhou and ZUN himself.
As a first step, we need to make Satorin the main character of CDS again!
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>50840804 you guys have no theory of mind lol. this argument comes mainly as a combination of factors, the narrative aspect is second to things like reusing assets, using AI generated assets, removing features (which is atrocious in 19 but has been a thing since 8), the licensing of mcdonals ads and LW, i would claim that the refusal to license an anime is cognitive dissonance regarding the last part, but he did license the ufotable one and because it was only shown on theaters its now lost media. he gets a lot of merit for his lax copyright too, but he was kinda forced into those conditions since early touhou did use copyrighted material which is probably why he barely ever acknowledges pc98
this is all without even mentioning more subjective reasons, such has having a massive cast yet barely using most of the characters, retconning shit, forgetting shit, having inconsistent characterizations between the works and just his general apathy towards the lore...
you might not agree with the sentiment itself and it may come off as ungrateful, but there are legitimate reasons to criticise him and deflecting those as "must be nogames" or "le yuritards" is just a cope
>>
>>
File: FqcZcQEX0AIQbhE.png (234.8 KB)
234.8 KB PNG
>>50842083
>but he was kinda forced into those conditions since early touhou did use copyrighted material which is probably why he barely ever acknowledges pc98
I hate most of ZUN's decisions as much as you. But this sounds as retarded as that one time when fans gaslight themselves that he wouldn't use Shinki because he doesn't own the character.
No one on this godforsaken planet gives a flying fuck about copyright outside of hack teenage artists on Twitter and some corporations. And most of the alleged "stolen" assets are nothingburgers too. The only real deal was pic rel, where he thought it was a good idea to trace from based Rance; otherwise they're transformative enough to be different on their own.
The whole reason why he hardly acknowledges pc-98 is because they're outdated in his eyes. He loves the reboot even more. Spoilers:It's not EoSD.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>50842083
You're the faggot who's been bitching on xitter about the lack of a score system in muh phantasmagoria game like its an actual detriment for the game despite the fact it has double the ammount of content
Actual retarded take. Seriously, kill yourself, you absolute fuckwad.
>>
>>
>>
File: 20231211_235904.jpg (2.8 MB)
2.8 MB JPG
>>50840804
Guy in the screencap here, I probably should've worded it better but this was a throwaway post I thought wouldn't get any attention so I didn't bother. What I meant was I felt that the quality of Zun's offerings have declined considerably over the past decade to the point where I feel he will never produce anything that stands shoulder to shoulder with his earlier works, and anything he puts out nowadays reeks of apathy, from gameplay to music to his attempts at worldbuilding. I'm in agreement that the games don't need any sort of epic storyline beyond an excuse to get the player through six levels, but this doesn't apply to story-driven mangas like FDS. Mega Man 4 and 7 are two of the best games in the classic series by the way.
>>50841845
This but with marriage and pregnancy and I would instantly forgive him
>>
aggressive2hu and faggots like him are genuinely insufferable, yes I disagree with some of his decisions and I think he should focus on his improvement and doing his best but their complaints mostly consist of what they want to see personally (i.e muh hedcanin, peesee 98, zun ban yuri and noofags it makes no leak) instead of things that would genuinely improve him, the community and the games.
Whenever they don't get their way they cry about him being LE CORPORATE JOO SHILL and when they do they find something else to bitch about they are the Touhou version of shartyfags
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: what_happened_with_our_circle.png (1.6 MB)
1.6 MB PNG
>>50842227
I really hope that fag BeatMario doesn't get a say in anything.
You can defend him claiking he is a "true otaku", unhinged and perverted, but most of falling in this category are the self-referential, trope galore retards who "can't see the forest for the trees".
Even if ZUN gives a time of his life to his friend, I believe he would rather have a Miyazaki type as a " sucessor", someone who really cares about themes and inspiration sources.
>>
>>
File: Screenshot 2026-04-11 101032.png (15.3 KB)
15.3 KB PNG
>>50842567
>aggressive2hu
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>50842614
Yes, and it's this guy >>50843662
>>
>>
File: twitter.webm (1.7 MB)
1.7 MB WEBM
>>
>>
>>
>>50840433
I... agree that ZUN is very annoying and not really that great of a developer, but the issue is that due to nature of doujin works you cannot remove him. Removing ZUN would mean removing Touhou, you're removing a fan from a fan work and that's super retarded.
Obviously, there's also a point to be made that Touhou Project's status of doujin work is really just an illusion nowadays because there's like half a dozen of various semi-commercial products related to it, but that's a different issue.
>>
>>
>>
>>50842083
>having a massive cast yet barely using most of the characters
how do you accomplish that while still keeping to the shmup genre and maintaining the 5-6 newhu output
CDS is the muh nostalgia title since it's made exactly to include every character from every game since 6, and it's getting lambasted for being all over the place
>>50843870
permissions can be rescinded, yes it would burn all bridges possible but heirs often are retarded
>>
>>
>>50844117
I wish ZUN would use BAiJR format more often. I would trade monthly whaletits for bi-yearly book with articles that are equivalent to chapters synopsis and post-article talks as a way to show some personality from involved people. Maybe it would even force ZUN to vary cast more often.
>>
>>
File: __shameimaru_aya_and_shameimaru_aya_touhou_drawn_by_yakousei_no_kame__d202d01e98d1925a3a164d3a31a67147.jpg (816.2 KB)
816.2 KB JPG
>>50844139
あや, 文, it's all about literature, isn't it? And when we talk about literature, it's only natural to think of the very best.
>>
>>
File: 60daa5834b5db.png (40.7 KB)
40.7 KB PNG
>>50844016
>you're removing a fan from a fan work and that's super retarded
If Touhou really is a derivative work. It's a derivative of what exactly? You can make the argument that it's based of Pocky & Rocky (which it is). But it's more in the territory of "inspired by" than sharing the same universe as each other. Even since day 1 is different enough to be it's own thing.
>>50844116
You can do it for free as long as it's staying under the radar. I.E staying indie.
>>
>>50844275
>If Touhou really is a derivative work. It's a derivative of what exactly
NTA but It's that kind of thing that depends on where you draw the line between derivative and inspired.
Personally I don't think it's fair to call Touhou truly derivative even though it does border on that line especially in the older games (PC98-EOSD) often taking things from other franchises pretty shamelessly.
>>
>>50844275
>If Touhou really is a derivative work. It's a derivative of what exactly?
Kokugaku scholarship.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>50844275
2hu is just Shinto fanfiction, it goes so far beyond being rooted in shinto. Half the final bosses are just gods turned into women. Maintaining a status quo (stagnation of the franchise) for a balanced world is peak shinto.
>>
>>
>>
File: Screenshot_2026-04-12_21-34-53.png (41.4 KB)
41.4 KB PNG
>>50841019
this. picrel is a yt comment from a video of alice's MS theme. you see a lot of comments like this for other themes
>>
>>
File: 7a42a2d3dfece7576140b5f842342709.jpg (91.5 KB)
91.5 KB JPG
>>50840804
>>50850966
>>50849973
>>50840433
I only delve into touhou last year but isn't the whole point of the games to be a place where ZUN can release his music? Everything else such as a story, writing, lore is secondary no?
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>50842439
Nigga tries to explain himself after making an objectively vitriolic and vindictive statement. It’s evident you and your friends go beyond simply disliking his current work, you hate him and those around him personally. By your xeets you made before this, you’re obviously a man who has always been this way and for once one of your many inflammatory tweets got a small bit of attention and were publicly humiliated for it. You’re less like smug critics or rebels against a “corrupt greedy hack” and more like the Latinx who killed himself because Bjork fucked some other guy.
>>
>>
File: twitter posting.jpg (656.1 KB)
656.1 KB JPG
>>50840433
>>
>>
>>50856247
>>50856119
You are exactly what's wrong with the fanbase.
>>
File: mhmm..png (4.8 KB)
4.8 KB PNG
>>50856292
Are you ok?
>>