//lit/
Emily > Charlotte > Anne
Showing all 12 replies.
>>
Correct, though Villette is really good, better than Jayne Eyre and maybe on par with Wuthering Heights.
>>
I love brontosaurus
>>
>>25327315
Tenant mogs everything Charlotte ever wrote
>>
>>25327335
t. has not read Villette
>>
>>25327371
I'm currently 3/4ths the way through my first read through. I'll grant you it's better than Jane Eyre but I hate the way Charlotte plots have to have all these random connections between the characters. The relationship between Lucy and Paul is also not nearly as well developed as Jane and Rochester. I thought Shirley was a more interesting premise but it never felt like it came together cohesively.
>>
>>25327315
Charlotte > Anne > Emily
>>
>>25327382
Lucy isndeliberately witholding information and leaving emotional holes though.
>>
I wonder why Emily didn't write more, Wuthering Heights was amazing
>>
>>25328873
Dying took much of the wind out of her sails. She was maybe working on a second novel but nothing has survived.

She did write a lot of pretty decent poetry. Much of it is set in her fantasy world, Gondal. So you get just someone mourning or defying or vowing vengeance or something, but with no context. If she had only written down all the background lore I think Gondal would have proved a fictional setting at least as good as, say, Narnia or Gormenghast. Could have made a classic series of children’s books. But she and Anne were happy to keep it as their private thing and only ever talk about it or refer to it obliquely in letters.
>>
>>25328873
She left another manuscript IIRC which one of the sisters burned because it was simply 'too scsndalous'.
>>
>>25328918
Charlotte did, and she also suppressed the release of Tenant of Wildfell Hall because of the same reason
>>
>>25328873
Some people only have the strength for a single monumental work in them

Reply to Thread #25327315


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)