Thread #43130648
HomeIndexCatalogAll ThreadsNew ThreadReply
H
Previous Thread (#143) >>43019151
https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/43019151

Fun is mandatory.

>What is this thread about?
This thread is dedicated to stories that have clear dominate and submissive roles; both with and without consent.

>What exactly is welcome in this thread?
A wide variety of stories are welcomed here; from non-consent and sexual slavery, to abusive manipulation and psychological domination, to maids and extortion, and even healthy consensual relationships with BDSM role-play elements.

Other variations are welcome as well, so long as they are complementary to the domination/submission focus of the thread.

Up to date archives:
Thread story list: https://ponepaste.org/7575
Thread list: https://ponepaste.org/7446
Unsorted oneshots/prompts/unfinished greens: https://ponepaste.org/7672

Outdated archives:
https://poneb.in/f8f09HB4
https://poneb.in/778zgnJ5
https://mulpwiki.batpony.party/index.php/SiM

——————

Historical Note:
This thread was originally founded to support the “Submission is Mandatory” story by MrNameless. While the story has gone on hiatus, it’s content is referred to by a number of stories in this thread.

Submission is Mandatory by MrNameless (Recommended)
Nightmare Moon summons Anon to defeat the EoH. In return, she grants him ownership of the Mane 6.
https://poneb.in/ycY3zrvA

(Non-Canon SiM Expanded Universe Stories)
Octavia POV (Recommended) https://poneb.in/Y2AahdQp
Other Stories - https://poneb.in/3AFdqxvs

——————

Remember not to save anything of value on pastebin. Use ponepaste.org
Have a broken pastebin link? Replace pastebin.com with poneb.in

——————
Active stories:
Last updated in #143:
>The Stables by AT
Stories about an underground club for humans and mares who want an outlet from the herd lifestyle.
Unarchived content:
Starts here >>42676952
Last update here >>42843494
>Broken Incentives by AT
A story about pony slavery in a post dimensionally fractured Earth.
https://ponepaste.org/user/AT_123

>The Carat and Stick by RapeApe !bwwXn5Gx.o
Cadance forces Rarity onto medifag Anon.
https://ponepaste.org/733 https://ponepaste.org/4327 https://ponepaste.org/9692
Non canon spin-off: https://ponepaste.org/9701
End of the last update: >>43027935

>Untitled
Mare sells herself to a new life as a sensory deprived possession.
>>43104332

Last updated in #141:
>The Culture of Rubber Ponies by ManicQuil
Ponies covered in latex.
https://ponepaste.org/7692
End of the last update: >>42930353

Last updated in #138/138.1:
>Oneshot with Twilight and Luna
>>42427087

Last updated (completed) in #135:
>Pink Haze by Glimbrain
Anon is bullied by three pink mares, but what goes around comes around.
https://ponepaste.org/10656, https://ponepaste.org/10809, https://ponepaste.org/10866, https://ponepaste.org/11063
Final update: >>42233797
+Showing all 181 replies.
>>
>>43130648
Last updated in #133.1:
>Shadowbolt story
A shadowbolt operative going on an infiltration mission.
https://ponepaste.org/10844( temporary ponepaste)
https://ponepaste.org/10852 ( unlisted backup of the above)
WIP of the setting used for the story:
https://ponepaste.org/10675

Last updated in thread #132:
>How to train a Scootaloo
Scootaloo receives a special kind of Wonderbolts training.
https://ponepaste.org/10804 ( Temporary paste )
https://ponepaste.org/10827 ( Unlisted backup of the above paste)
WIP of the setting used for the story:
https://ponepaste.org/10675

Last updated in threads #127 and #127.1:
>Untitled
The perfect Accessory to own.
Starts here: >>41365586

Last updated in #126:
>Harsh is The Night by ManicQuil
EQG story with a sub Rainbow Dash and her mistress Luna.
Starts here: >>40261868
Last update here: >>41332381

Last updated in #124:
>Thralls of Twilight by ManicQuil
The retired princesses show Twilight a new hidden side in their relationship.
Starts here: >>41137667
Last updated here: >>41137667

Last updated in #121:
>Short EQG christmas story with Dom Celestia and sub Dazzlings by ManicQuil
Starts here: >>40663996
Ends here: >>40670457

Last updated in #118:
>Untitled
Applebloom trying out a special outfit for Nightmare Night
Starts here: >>40211580
Last update here: >>40241892
>>
There, sorry for the delay. AT I hope that description for the incentives story is okay, I didnt want to just post the name and nothing else.
>>
I plan to bump it a few times, but if everyone would rather wait a few more days before getting back to it, we could make the thread again on the weekend.
>>
>>43130665
Is correct, thanks.

And I'm surprised.

Was expecting that the board would be back on a month.

Here, is the final chapter of Incentives:
https://ponepaste.org/11824
>>
>>43130988
I wouldnt have let it stay off the board for that long, unless activity was really dead.
But if people here really want a break we could go for one for a week or two after RapeApe put out his update, and maybe after Keeper put out his as well.

>https://ponepaste.org/11824
Nice ending. When Trixie was losing her composure at that moment I thought she had synched with Limestone to feel what she was feeling.
>>
>>43131035
Nah, she is an egotist Mare.

She will never share what her human made he feel.

Passing of that, I'm gonna work on another part of Thai AU, I'm undecided between shorts of the ex-princess and the hellish days or a Yandere Spitfire that invade the life of her love O his live.

The one of Diamond Tiara, needs a few more day to polish some scenes. Then maybe I can upload on this week or the next...

May be.
>>
>>43131075
>Then maybe I can upload on this week or the next
Looking forward to that one, and the Yandere Spitfire idea sounds interesting too.
>>
>>43131075
Oh wait, wasnt there going to be something explaining what the other races like the dragons, gryphons, etc did that in that AU ?
>>
>>43131098
Yep, I'm still writing it.

Griffins and Dragons of G4 are something hard to explain why the system works on them.

The Griffin are more stronger than a Pony, without magic and Dragons are sources living of Magic, so I'm dealing with a good point to use them like slaves on the human world or the others equestrias, the same with the Kirins.

Teasthreal and other variant like Hipoogrif fall with the system, because Pony's use magic and can be controlled.
>>
>>43131317
So the issue is what kind of restraints they would have to be kept controlled.

>Dragons are sources living of Magic
You mean indirectly, because magic creates the gems that they eat ?
>>
>>
>>43132079
Ugh...

Damn, I was operating on DND logic. The existence of dragons create magic on the world.

Well, it's gonna be better to rewrite it and other options.

That's one, now to deal with the Kirins and Griffins.
>>
>>43132481
You could try bondage on the dragons with welded on metal restraints, made from an alloy that not even their fire could melt.
Or use their lizard factor and segregate them to cold places to keep their fire weakened because of the low internal heat.
>>
File: 44523872.jpg (382.4 KB)
382.4 KB
382.4 KB JPG
Deleted a few pages of writing cause it was shit. Trying to think of a nice format for presenting that, Rainbow Dash grooms Scootaloo into a 'better' version of herself. With eventual escalation to wearing Dashie latex~ Diary and QA style things are fun in concept....
>>
>>43132576
The idea sounds good but I'm not seeing what Dash could do to her besides controlling her looks. Molesting maybe ? Make her live out a "wonderbolt relief mare" fantasy she had in her training days ?
>>
>>43132731
Kink driven BDSM wish fulfillment fantasy essentially. Dash trying more and more hardcore stuff on a devoted teen. While trying to tell herself that it's fine cause she'd totally have done that herself.
>>
File: 3786526.jpg (156 KB)
156 KB
156 KB JPG
>>
Teaser of Diamond Tiara AU:

The heavy forged-metal door barely muffled the vulgar moans and screams coming from inside.

Inside the luxurious room, a gray earth pony with a silver mane lay blindfolded on the large bed, her body arched in an uncomfortable but deliberate position. Two humans were using her relentlessly — one buried deep in her marehood, the other claiming her tailhole with rough, synchronized thrusts.

Every powerful movement drew desperate, broken sounds from her. Pleasure had long since overwritten any discomfort. Her flanks quivered with each impact.

One of the men brought his hand down hard on her right flank.

SMACK.

She came instantly — body convulsing, a pathetic, high-pitched whine escaping her as both men finished inside her, flooding her with their seed.

They pulled out and let her collapse onto the sheets like a discarded toy, cum leaking from both holes.

A refined yet arrogant voice cut through the heavy air.

“Look at you… exactly how I wanted you.”

The two humans stepped aside as a pink-coated mare entered the room, smiling with elegant cruelty.

Silver Spoon trembled on the bed, still panting.

“Silver Spoon,” Diamond Tiara said sweetly, “I hope you understand your place as my trophy wife. You exist only to please me. Do you understand?”

Silver Spoon’s voice came out weak, trembling with sickening ecstasy:

“Yes… my Mistress…”
>>
>>43130648
I submit to ponk
>>
>>43132940
>trying more and more hardcore stuff on a devoted teen.
With plenty of corruption involved for said teen?
>>
>>43133647
>With plenty of corruption involved for said teen?
Definitely. - Both in terms of Dash pushing her interests on her, and the 'damage' that causes. And Dash taking the leap from 'just teaching my younger sibling' to 'having a mini dash pet'
>>
>>43133344
A prelude from before Silver's chaste days ?
>>
White knight general died. Again.
>>
How long until the relationship between those two reach this point ?
>>
>>43134753
Immediately. Coco is a desperate sub, literally cannot function without a confident pretty mare telling her what to do.
>>
How to ruin one's tail.
https://derpibooru.org/images/3737439
>>
>>43134866
I meant in the Carat story. I think she still hasnt put on any collars.
>>
File: 3733947.jpg (154.3 KB)
154.3 KB
154.3 KB JPG
>>
>>43135601
Where is the red ribbon from her tail? She has her legs tied.
>>
Ah, just did my annual re-read of Broken Bluebird.
I've gone through a lot of fics and greens in my time in this fandom, but I don't think anything has ever made me feel the way that story did (and often still does). It has one of the most well-executed tragic endings I've come across: the villains-eye-view of the heroic plot that foils him; that he wins over Dash and isolates loyalty in the end; that his trauma from space corpo-tyranny so directly injures him beyond any ability to believe in redemption from ponies even as Chrysalis is literally telling him about how they spared her for a sob story; that this lack of faith so convincingly leads to his choosing death. I read Dash's self-imposed isolation in the epilogue and I all at once both despise this Anon and yearn for his salvation. His motivations, his traumas, his responses to limited information, are excellently realized, and the stalemate the story presents is a sophisticated and challenging mix of countering capacities and motivations, even if the realpolitik itself does not always live up.
I didn't think I'd enjoy a non-sexual BDSM/abuse story. I was shocked at how illicit and stirring some of the content was, especially the scenes where he shows dash off to her friends. The somewhat contrived main torture method aside, all of their small interactions are highly on-target and each scene is loaded with physicality. Anon picking up Dash by her collar and walking her back against a wall probably caused more of an awakening in me than the first time I read a rape scene. It's not easy to nail "master" dialog, it being an art of contestation and power, and harder still to balance it with meaningful flaws and imperfections - this Anon is direct and biting, yet never bereft of human warmth. Though the author's skill clearly improves in the later installments, the earliest scenes between them are still some of my go-tos when I wonder what a disciplinarian should sound like in writing.
That the ponies, too, are on-point, in-character, and that the story is thrumming with their strengths and triumphs, is an elevation in a medium that too often refuses to take them seriously. BB remains the greatest kindergrim tightrope act I've seen in the fandom of ponies being both MLP characters and real agents capable of fathoming and standing up to cruelty. Perhaps that is why the ending always gives me such heartache: the ponies are so strong, why did they have to lose the fight for Dash's heart? Alas.
I wish Anon had lived, I wish that Dash had stayed among her friends, I wish they both could have healed and stayed together. I wish they could all win, I wish they would all lose. Broken Bluebird made me yearn with an intensity that little else in the fandom ever has.
>>
>>43138765
I really should pick up and read it someday.
>>
>>43139237
I strongly recommend it.
Fuck, now I'm thinking I should have used spoilers. Feels like it's like spoiler Harry Potter at this point though.
>>
>>43139285
No worries, its sounds like the kind of story where execution matters a lot a more than whatever it is that could be spoiled.
>>
>>43139237
There are people who have not yet read it?
It's a 10 year old story at this point. One of the best.
>>
>>
>>43140794
I hope somewhere these images still exist in full resolution.
>>
bump
>>
have we yet seen the creation of a topping-from-the-bottom fic called Domination Is Mandatory?
>>
>>43141779
Not yet but it would be a nice idea.
And it would be an interesting take if it was mixed with a strong matriarchal Equestria where all mares, even the ones with power, saw topping as a degrading habit for them to partake.
>>
>>43141829
Forgot to link a related image
https://derpibooru.org/images/2712245
>>
>>43133344
Not that having her man servants do acts like this isnt hot, and it would be even more so if Silver was only into mares, but Im wondering if she will have other means of power play to use on her and the CMCs.
>>
>>
>>43126532
It's been 47 days!
>>
>>43144454
Soon 48!
>>
Anything we could talk about in the meantime ? Scenarios, AUs, pairings ?
>>
>>43143489
Silver Spoon is an asset, she is what her mistress want.

She blindly love Diamond Tiara, so she would do anything for her.
>>
>>43145800
>blind love
Oh thats the best kind of leash for a sadist mistress to hold.
>>
Any hypno anons lurking here ?
>>
>>43148998
I'd actually love to see an image of Trixie and Starlight fully encased in their Twilight and Rarity disguises or even a squeal that shows Luna joining in on the fun giving Celestia a break as Trixie and Starlight watch
>>
>>43149579
>Luna and Celestia
I had a fun edit idea with those two, where they would be wrapped and sealed onto two sarcophaguses as part of a "passing the crown" ritual, with a nervous Twilicorn watching it happening with a grinning Sphinx sitting by her side.
>>
OK, part one of the Diamond Collection:
https://ponepaste.org/11833

It's the same universe, yes I'm lazy and work is holding me by the balls in a really wrong way.

I curse you damn world and your crazy clients. Sorry for the rant, ^^
>>
>>43150311
I didnt think you would use the incentives AU for this.

>Apple Bloom.
>And the rest of her little friends.
>Brought to her as personal incentives.

Does she plan to get the non-guilty ones from her broken universe ?
>>
>>43148203
I am, I was thinking of waiting for a while before re-creating the thread. Why do you ask?
>>
>>43150442
I wanted talk with someone about mean quirks a dom would condition onto her sub. Something like what was used on Twilgiht in the rubber ponies story.
>>
File: 3584159.png (3 MB)
3 MB
3 MB PNG
>>
>>43150471
Oh wow it’s been a while since I thought about the rubber ponies.

What did you have in mind?

I saw something recently with a rune collar, that had a a lot of potential modifications. Things like punishment in proportion to the crime so things like thoughts would be minor, but actual acts of defiance would, hurt. Also things like love, and submissive conditioning, in the form of rewards for obedience and love.
>>
>>43151772
>What did you have in mind?
For now just something small that would make a pony want to stay fully gagged, a quirk that makes it feel a really awful taste in it's mouth, that cant be overwhelmed by anything that isnt rubber, cum and whatever else her owner decided to condition into the sub's mental whitelist.

>things like thoughts would be minor
It could be nerve wracking in its own way, imagine if the collar had a marker system that could tick off fake ones just to keep the pony's mind from relaxing.
>>
>>43151772
Actually, I've also been thinking about kink conditioning, and how it could be mixed with an arousal linking spell. It could make for a good dynamic where the slave's body gets trained into liking whatever the owner is into using the proxy arousal as the main tool.It could even go in a more unbalanced direction, where the owner's ever escalating depraved fantasies would push the slave into becoming the kinky freak of the duo.
https://derpibooru.org/images/1165502
>>
>>
>>43151930
Hmm, when you say kink condoning I already love it, it would be a great way to make sure that your slave, is obedient yes, but also that she is tied to you, since most other masters might not have the same kinks.

But I am more curious about the proxy arousal, like do you mean that the slaves feels what her owner feels so she feels the pleasure her master feels seeing her all tied up and bound, or is it an artificial feelings. I ask because what if that was expanded so that the slave felt what her master felt when he claimed her.
>>
>>43151813

> gagged, a quirk that makes it feel a really awful taste in it's mouth, that cant be overwhelmed by anything that isnt rubber, cum and whatever else her owner decided to condition into the sub's mental whitelist.

Hmm is taste the objective or gagging, because you could also employ texture and discomfort. Like give her a massive oral fixation, or something like the discomfort/ocd twilight feels when everything is not perfect. Maybe make it feel wrong, for the slave to exist without a gag, and if they ever manage to get free of it they are unconsciously grabbing for things to gag themselves with purely out of habit.

> that could tick off fake ones

What do you mean like randomly punish her, very lightly. To say she had a disobedient thought even if she didn’t.
>>
>>43152181
>she is tied to you, since most other masters might not have the same kinks.
Didnt think of that. It would make for a nice way of marking her as yours and ruining her for others, kinda like corruption but without visible changes to her look. https://derpibooru.org/images/3647552

>she feels the pleasure her master feels seeing her all tied up and bound
Like that, just having her owner gazing at her tied up or used by strangers would make her feel it as her own arousal.
And if it had some feedback it would make her want to hold her own arousal buildup in the hopes that it doesnt push her owner's perversion further.

>what if that was expanded so that the slave felt what her master felt when he claimed her
Oh that would bring a new play to this. Enhanced kink conditioning with a whole new set of sensations and a really in depth learning on how that kink turns her owner on, with the same weak spots eventually becoming hers as well.
If you applied that feedback idea, a same sex owner might try living out a hardcore fantasy through the slave like a voodoo sex doll.
https://derpibooru.org/images/1167897
>>
>>43152199
The objective is having that discomfort in her life, big or small depending on what kind of taste she's getting, that can only be avoided with the gag option.

>Maybe make it feel wrong, for the slave to exist without a gag, and if they ever manage to get free of it they are unconsciously grabbing for things to gag themselves with purely out of habit.
That would be a hot alternative, although thats more of an addiction play rather than a discomfort avoidance one. Maybe her owner's dick could be one of the whitelisted tastes.

>What do you mean
Picture her collar showing something, maybe a glowing tally mark, to signal that she had a disobedient thought, and that mark sometimes didnt light up immediatly but instead it dimmed between stages just to mess with her mind.
>>
>>
>>43141829
You know, that's an interesting idea. Like a matriarchy setting where mares impose a strong expectation for stallions to put on traditionally masculine performances to entertain them with. They just see topping as emotional labor and have a kind of aristocratic disdain for it.
>>
>>43153770
>They just see topping as emotional labor and have a kind of aristocratic disdain for it.
And that could happen even among the lesbians, who wouldnt want to be seen as the "piston" in the relationship.
>>
>>43152312
Hmm, so like it would wait a while before triggering, so that she would not know when the effect would happen and the anticipation would build up at her. maybe thought that seems more focused on discomfort then training.

Though I do like the glowing tally thing as a way to track how disobedient she is. Also yes her owners cock should always be a whitelisted item, in fact it should be the item that gives her the most comfort and pleasure.

You could also try and give her ocd, compulsions, where the mare is like it’s a really minor thing so I better do it, in case something silly happens.


Maybe even force OCD onto Cozy Glow, to make sure she learns her place, and then her strategic mind can be used to torture her.
>>
>>43153952
>thought that seems more focused on discomfort then training
I like a resigned attitude so thats kind of the objective in this. The alternative is not meant to bring comfort, but a lesser discomfort. She wouldnt be sucking that cock with a happy face but an angry or resigned look, cause that taste will probably linger for some time before the default awful one comes back.

>OCD onto Cozy Glow, to make sure she learns her place
Feels like something Twilight would have come with.
I cant think of a complex strategic one, but what about something demeaning and fitting for her height, such as a hoof cleaning obsession ?
>>
>>43153770
What if the setting had that typical lack of stallions problem, and mare servants sometimes had that unfortunate role forced onto them ?
Someone of a dignified status >>43153568 who had a bad stroke of luck in life and ended up being the strapon wielder to a lonely mistress who makes her servant sweat her heart out from all the beast like actions she makes her do behind doors.
>>
I tried doing a nun color edit of that Ember image.
>>
>>43154574
Good job
>>
>>
>>43156373
"Darling, that's not what Applejack meant when she said she wanted us to be her Bunnies to play with."
>>
File: 3791177.png (1.8 MB)
1.8 MB
1.8 MB PNG
>>43150311
>>
>>43156685
Thanks, cute and kinky at the same time.

Still working on part 2, but RLF is getting out of control.

Passing of that, how do you see a dragoness being tamed.

Pure physical pain or mental trauma?
>>
>>43156781
Physical pain. And speaking of it, what do you think of heat shrinking restraints or outfits >>43154574 as a tool for that ?
Not just to prevent firebreathing attempts, but to also add a torturous factor to where the cold blooded dragoness could stay to gather warmth without feeling her lungs being squeezed out.
>>
>>43156854
That is more for trauma, but it can be a good punishment, now a have a good scene.
And something else to use on Kirins.
>>
>>43156854
I love the idea of dragons being fit with a rebreather gag so if they try to use their fire it causes their own smoke to smother them.
>>
>>43157363
I do like that idea. Maybe it could be combined somehow with a lantern gag ?
>>
>>43156859
Metal bondage could be an option too if you want to cover the heat shrinking suit with something unscratchable and make it extra inescapable.
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/63642199/
Oh and I didnt emphasize it before but the cold blooded thing could make her needy for ANY kind of warmth, especially the internal kind that doesnt affect her suit.
https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/42837665/#42851784
>>
>>43154026
I see I more like the mental aspect of it, as someone into mind control, but if your into discomfort you could make them like it, and have to live with that. Like rarity for example having to live with the fact that she is captured, enslaved, and the only respite is acting like a slutty, trashy whorse, like making her masters cock a drug, and have her deal with the effects of basically being an addict, hating that she loves it.


I like the hoof cleaning one, another thing could be twilight’s worry, and desire for approval so cozy cunt is still evil however even after she takes over equestria she needs constant praise and reassurance.

Could be a fun green, Cozy glow is in charge of equestria, but twilight left all sorts of levers in her brain, that Anon has to use to tame the vengeful cozy without her catching on to his plan.
>>
>>43158266
What about giving her a growing need to feel enclosed and cozy, that would escalate into a bondage addiction ?
>>
>>43158266
>if your into discomfort you could make them like it, and have to live with that
Doesnt work the same. Making it into an addiction turns the whole act into a wanted reward that would make her happy, instead of it being a degrading undignified thing she would choose to do for some respite. Not to mention her master might prefer seeing a defiant glare out of her instead of a happy broken smile.
>>
>>43158436
I disagree think of cozy or rarity trying to break her addiction and hating every second of her existence trying to resist only to fall again, and feel terrible about herself.
>>
>>
File: 3691935.jpg (1.2 MB)
1.2 MB
1.2 MB JPG
>>
Bump
>>
>>43134377
And again...
>>
>>43158594
I think I would like that angle more if it came with a whole kink corruption set, like for example if it was an elegant mare being unawarely conditioned by someone into only getting off to the hardcore, bdsm kind of sex.
>>
>>43150311
>>43150370
In case she picks this route, she could do an identity erasure play on one of the CMCs.
>>
>>43160158
Its getting hard to keep this one alive too.
>>
>>43162664
You said hard uhhhhuhuhuhuh uhhhhuhuhuhuhuhuh
>>
>>43162105
This mare needs her naughty little pussy and ponut positively pounded by Anon's rock hard cock (after her bare bottom is blistered bright red)!
>>
>>43162762
I agree, except the blistering red bottom. It should be just slightly red, else she gets used to it and loses sense of it.
>>
Bump
>>
>Anon still wont remove her belt.
>>
>>43149420
Best couple
>>
>>43133904
How about a hanging bed like this for a pegasus pet ?
https://derpibooru.org/images/3795912
>>
>>43163284
>>
>>43165093
UNF
>>
>>43165674
>>
>>43163795
>>
>>43167325
I wish I was Vinyl there
>>
>>43167850
Hot, I love seeing them make love
>>
P10 bump
>>
>>43168104
https://derpibooru.org/images/2629207
>>
>>43169116
Very nice
>>
>>43169241
Just to bring a /sim/ element into their relationship, who do you see as the most jealous and possessive one in the pair ?
Cause I keep thinking of Vinyl as a hypocritical slut.
>>
>>43169635
I don't think Vinyl would cheat on Tavi out of fear of losing her and never getting to plap that fancy donkey ever again, even if she was the biggest slut in town before they met. The only way it's happening is if Tavi is into Vinyl fucking around which sounds like the opposite of possessive and jealous
Octavia, on the other hand is a cultured and disciplined mare who wouldn't give in to lustful desires at the expense of her love. If for whatever reason she stopped loving Vinyl and was interested in somepony else then she'd break up with her pretty quickly claiming they simply aren't compatible

To answer your question, I don't really think it matters. What does matter is who would actually act on it if push came to shove, even if Tavi was more jealous and possessive I don't think she'd take any action further than breaking up with her if she learned of Vinyl being promiscuous because going around declaring that Vinyl is hers like a cavepony would be uncouth and unlike her while Vinyl would probably confront you if you stared at Tavi for too long
>>43170091
Kiss already
>>
>>43170200
>Octavia, on the other hand is a cultured and disciplined mare who wouldn't give in to lustful desires at the expense of her love.
This would be a buildup for a really kinky compromise, but what if she was the kind of sub who valued submission more than sex itself ? And she liked how controlling Vinyl could get in her moments of jealousy ?
>>
>>43170443
If she merely wanted Vinyl to be jealous in order to get dominated and plapped harder then I could see her talking to other ponies in front of Vinyl but that's pretty much it, I don't see Octavia as the type of mare to risk jeopardizing a loving relationship by actively denying attention to Vinyl
Tavi would likely feel guilty after thinking of how she would feel if Vinyl stopped giving her attention in favor of other ponies even after she made it clear that it makes her jealous and she doesn't like it
>>
>>43170935
>>
File: vinyl.png (1.4 MB)
1.4 MB
1.4 MB PNG
>>43170552
>to be jealous in order to get dominated and plapped harder
Not that sex wouldnt be welcome to her, but I meant her being much more into the servicing part. Think of it like those freaky, almost asexual sub types in bdsm stories, who are only in it for the servitude experience because its what really hits the spot for them.
And because someone with a low libido like that wouldnt be a good match for Vinyl, Tavi would want to poke into that jealousy and possessive streak to push Vinyl towards a solution that bound her even more to her marefriend >>43151930
>>
>>43171432
Ehhhh I just don't see it working out, if Tavi is naturally not a good match for Vinyl and has to make her feel jealous by I'm gonna assume giving attention to other ponies in order to save their relationship then I could see it falling apart very easily
Why would Vinyl be so possessive over somepony who's not compatible with her anyway? If Tavi's just that attractive to her to the point where she would overlook their compatibility then I feel like Vinyl should be the one putting the effort into pushing Tavi towards yearning for sex
>>
>>43172404
To be fair I had these ideas for a far more unequal relationship between those two, so Im kinda trying to make them fit into this more consensual case.
>Why would Vinyl be so possessive over somepony who's not compatible with her anyway?
Because one of those ideas was for Vinyl to really like the thought of having a devoting beauty like Octavia fantasizing over her but always being kept at a barely chaste reach.

>I feel like Vinyl should be the one putting the effort into pushing Tavi towards yearning for sex
Well that's where that proxy spell could come in. All the arousal and pleasure building felt by one would be felt by the other, but orgasm itself would only be achievable with eachother's touch.
>>
>>43170947
You got more images with Vinyl taking charge like that ?
>>
>>43172404
https://derpibooru.org/images/918844
>>
>>43174245
Here
>>43174612
I like the comments under that one
>>
File: 1848524.png (797.6 KB)
797.6 KB
797.6 KB PNG
>>43174649
I already know that one, but its still really good. Although it could use some ear biting, https://derpibooru.org/images/1848524

>comments
That's a lot of effort to justify liking art of a mare's face getting stuffed.
>>
>>43174826
How about this
>>
>>43174857
Never seen that one, I cant believe something this good was never uploaded in any booru.
>>
RapeApe is missing for an unusually long time.
>>
>>43174853
>>
>>43175572
The mare under the outfit.
>>
>>43175411
I actually got some meaningful writing done today! I need to pad out a scene that's proving troublesome, but the actual narrative for the next part is done.
>>
>>43175966
yay
>>
>>43175966
Nice to know!
https://derpibooru.org/images/1786056
>>
>>43175966
Any new scenes with Coco struggling with the belt ? Cause that clit trap mechanism could lead to so many teasing moments to drag her into.
>>
>>43175572
>>43175636
fantastico
>special talent is being a drone
I wonder if this mare wears the sensory deprivation voluntarily or if this part of the job somehow

Either way I kind of like the idea of her being full-time deprived while undressed, and not even gagged. If she can't hear anything she doesn't even have any reason to talk, she just has to silently obey even when her mouth is free
>>
>>43174990
upload it then
>>
File: 3750239.jpg (233.5 KB)
233.5 KB
233.5 KB JPG
>>
>>43174857
So have you ever had any unequal relationship ideas with those two ?
>>
>>43178241
I'm not really interested in that sort of thing, again it feels like their relationship would fall apart fast if one had to constantly do things like make the other feel jealous or cast lust spells to increase the other's libido because otherwise they would not be a good match
I can get behind the small, healthy amount of "unequalness" like Vinyl having to put in more effort to impress Tavi by dressing formally and learning classical music but that's it
>>
is submission mandatory?
>>
>>43178592
nah its optional
you can just disobey if you want
>>
>>43178634
If you like to be punished then go ahead.
>>
>>43178995
well shit
>>
>>43178634
If you like to be punished then go ahead.
>>
bump
>>
Is posting working here ?
>>
RapeApe keeps trying to delay the story with these site hiccups.
>>
>>43179417
Tavi is so damn freaky
>>
>>43179417
part 2 literally never
>>
>>43180130
She likes to take control too
>>
>>43180390
I like imagining that she's a switch, but made it a hard point of giving Vinyl full control whenever they are inside their house.

Reply to Thread #43130648


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)