But here, she can only exist in human form, so she now looks like an ordinary human woman, only vaguely resembling her true self in appearance (as much as that is even possible for a Flash animation character). However, her voice and personality remain unchanged.
The magic that brought her here can only work twice. She can still return to Equestria and even take you with her. But there will be no way back. And you, the same way, can only exist in Equestria in pony form.
But if you want, she will stay here with you forever, as a human woman.
>>43252015 >Wanting your waifu to live in an inferior form within a vastly inferior world Terrible. That point alone makes a life in Equestria the only option. Virtually all ponies would detest living here, and even more so in an alien shape.
>>43252048 Sure. But she'd still only be happy in Equestria. Meaning the options are either she leaves on her own or we leave together. And if given the chance, I'd go with her if she wants me to. It would be crazy not to join her.
>>43252015 Stay long enough to absorb all possible knowledge from this universe, then go back and use Equestrian time travel magic to live unlimited more lives there. Why choose?
(Also she's a grown-ass thousand year old horse, why am I choosing?)
>>43252015 I would never want to subject my tubby wubby to this world and its displeasures. I'd 'prefer' to be myself in Equestria, but frankly, being a pony would probably mean the transition period would be a lot easier; and I'd probably stick out less. Which might be a good or bad thing, depending on how large of a life I set out to live there. Regardless, being there with her, in any form, is worth it. Fuck, I'd go to equestria with her in the form of a salamander if I had to.
>>43252015 >only vaguely resembling her true self in appearance I don't even know who that is supposed to be in the image. Is that meant to be Luna or Nightmare? Or someone else like Inky?
>>43252015 >She can still return to Equestria and even take you with her. But there will be no way back. And you, the same way, can only exist in Equestria in pony form. ptfg chads can't stop winning
>>43252015 I rip her heart out and offer it to the god Obstenses in exchange for a pocket dimension of ponies for me and all of /mlp/. My waifu may be dead but it was not in vain if it means every anon here can be with their headcanon accurate waifu. I however will stay on Earth as punishment for sacrificing her.
>>43253825 I cannot approve of this because it involves you killing a pony. No amount of benefit for us is worth that sin. Just be with your waifu and be happy.
>>43253825 So dramatic. And what are you going to do when I destroy your pocket reality to discourage others from trying anything like that ever again? Think quickly, I don't have all day: there's still Obstenses to murder.
>>43252015 My life doesn't have room in it for someone else. I don't make enough money or have enough time. I'm always working but can't afford to stay afloat, my house is with family so I dont have room for another person in my life. Mare shouldn't see my loser state I live in.
>>43257153 not many people know that fallout 4's DLC Nuka World was inspired by FoE >amusement park with raiders >redeye i've never heard anypony mentioning this at least
>>43257168 >run an archive Is this some kind of porn reference? I don't think I've ever clopped to Scootaloo, let alone her human form. It was a weird dream but I enjoyed the attention she gave me. And she wasn't a child if that is what you are getting at.
>>43257179 >Is this some kind of porn reference? No, there was an idiot who runs a backup of pony literature and he went on a crusade to "filter" foalcon and expose its makers. Later he went full double standard because he admitted to waifu Scootaloo.
>>43252015 >The magic that brought her here can only work twice. She can still return to Equestria and even take you with her. But there will be no way back. And you, the same way, can only exist in Equestria in pony form. Anon, these hypotheticals are supposed to make you think, like, there's supposed to be a downside of some sort. Hell I ain't complaining though, TAKE ME HOME MOONY
>>43252066 I have been thinking about it for years by now. I never stopped dreaming about getting to Equestria, and never stopped loving Luna, ever since I was 16. It's been 15 years. I tried building a life, was even successful at it, but the yearning never stops. I did not acquire a single dream that is connected to this world. And knowing I would be leaving those who depend on me, Indo what I can for them now. But if Luna ever comes to take me, I just accepted being whatever leaving would make me. Over years, I even grew comfortable in becoming a pony, ironic, given I was a hardcore human in Equestria fantasiser.
>>43257623 It's hilarious that the mind would rather fantasize about the impossible and unattainable than even take a chance fantasizing about an outcome in this reality. Says a lot.
>>43252019 Anon... Something tells me you would not like Derpy as a human, women with her eyes exist irl right now and I don't see you or anyone calling them pretty...
>>43252857 Same. It's the part that anyone should be least proud of. The reason Equestria is so much better than Earth is literally because ponies are superior in morals, ethics and attitude. Humanity is a blight.
>>43252015 Become a pony and go to Equestria with her. I'd go under any circumstance, escaping this nightmare world is far more important than any physical form I or she might take on.
>>43252015 Since you've used AI for the OP pic, what would some of these vaguely pony resembling forms be? Especially those that aren't easy to identify by colors or hair alone. Because I reckon you couldn't even recognize most of them.
>>43263779 If their counterparts look only vaguely similar to their true pony forms, it could be pretty easy not to recognize some of them. Milky is an obvious giveaway though. She'd had to have an atomic bosom.
I'm starting to think >>43252015 has underestimated the Anons' attraction to horses. I bet he expected to have a more balanced discussion about pros and cons, and what he got instead was an overwhelming majority going pro horse on the spot.
>>43265140 Well if my only two choices are >have her here and chance her becoming retarded like all women or >become a pony I'd just stay here because I don't want to be a pony.
>>43265140 >I bet he expected to have a more balanced discussion about pros and cons, Maybe he shouldn't have asked "would you rather have 10 dollars or 10 million dollars?" then.
>>43265701 Well, enjoy your time on this hell, while I'll be enjoying my time in Equestria. Maybe you can get some high fives from internet strangers for your decision? I dunno, I'll be banging my waifu instead.
>>43265714 Oooh you sound a little agitated. Don't worry, tons of board trolls who'll cheer for you. Of course, it can't compare to the feeling of sex with your waifu, but gotta stick to those principles, huh?
>>43265694 I don't think people having an attachment to their body is a tribalism thing, most people on Earth would find any sort of deal that involves losing their body forever to be pretty unappealing. It's okay that you actively like the idea but you shouldn't assume that's the norm.
>>43265159 >Op is likely relatively new OP is likely a transformer making another transformer thread that prompts non-transformers to engage. Because no one with any morals is bringing a pony here to be turned into a foid. So there are anons that rejoice at being a pony, because that's what they wanted anyway. And other anons begrudgingly accepting their new pony life. And the rest deflecting the question.
i'd dearly miss all of my friends. i'd almost be inclined to take them with me if that were possible, but if not, i'd probably still go to Equestria; i hardly belong here though i see no reason not to go into deep debt and show her everything cool about earth. and of course, taking as many books as possible with us and seeing if solar-powered computers are a viable thing there's also the question of why she'd be attracted to me specifically. i'd be suspicous of weird metaphysical bullshit or demon succubi
>>43252015 No stipulation as to how long we can stay here for before leaving, so I'd introduce her to people and show her a bunch of actually good stuff first. Also collect as much as I can possibly take through to Equestria as well, along with a generator of some type to power electronics. At some point, say goodbyes and promise I'll be happy, and hopefully my crazy talk will be seen as true if she's an Alicorn sized human, then leave for Equestria.
I'll hope I'll be insanely lucky and become an Alicorn. If not, lucky and that I'll become a Unicorn, then try finishing a spell or whatever it is that turned Twilight into an Alicorn.
>>43252015 can i bring some trinkets from home and is it possible to have like a portal to go back and then back to equestria or is it a one and done thing stuck in equestria?
>>43257173 All mares in the show have the exact same model, and they only differentiate through colour, race, and accessories. Scientifically, the more unique you present yourself as a human, the more a mare would be interested in you (ergo picrel is irrelevant). In your scenario, wouldn't Rainbow Dash be the best choice? She can sleep in the clouds above your house if there's not enough room, and she can go anywhere she wants. Take her to Penn and Teller's Fool Us and become rich by doing magic shows with a flying pegasus.
>>43252015 >expecting anyone to choose Earth Holy newfag batman! But fine, fine; I'll be the contrarian and engage with the prompt. It's not as obvious as the OP makes it seem. It would really sting to leave behind all the people whom I care about, and I'd have to find a completely different job, too. That's a huge cost. But asking her to abandon her home and friends is insanely selfish, and Equestria is objectively a better place, too. Having the time to prepare and say goodbyes makes it easier for (You) than her, too.
While I think I'd prefer to stay human, I really don't think that's a huge deal, and she'd be able to comment on the differences. If the switch fucks up your brain chemistry somehow, things are more grim. But also what >>43252024 said, duh.
Here's a tricky one: Your waifu appears here on Earth as a mare, you can stay human and stay here with her or return to Equestria with her. However, if you return to Equestria with her she'll turn human and you'll become a pony.
>>43290069 Both suck. Staying here as a mare would be a nightmare for her because of Earth being Earth. And I wouldn't be so selfish to insist on her undergoing such a change just for me to go to Equestria. It would be way better for her to return to Equestria alone.
>>43290069 Is there any rules in the waifu like it being the pony you love most? What's stopping me from lets say waifuing Lyra and when I go to Equestria I then go to my true waifu.
>>43290238 Yeah, I wish ChatGPT could undress her or edit the other images where she's naked, but that's all we're going to get since Grok turned into a censorious bitch.
>>43290204 >some drawback It's not just some drawback. It gives you the choice of either subjecting your waifu to body horror or environmental horror. Neither of the two is pleasant. You could only make the case for one being worse than the other.