Thread #737049684
File: क्लेयर ओब्स्कुरः अभियानः ३३.jpg (639.2 KB)
639.2 KB JPG
This game not GOTY level of being good
87 RepliesView Thread
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1765504303087122.png (27.6 KB)
27.6 KB PNG
>>737049684
E33 fags have to be the most pretentious fags ever.
The story for this game isn't even good. The first 2 acts are a generic save the world plotline, while the final act is a failed allegory for escapism.
The escapism is bad message doesn't work because lumiere is basically a real dimension with real thinking people. At best you could argue the game keeps it ambiguous, but clearly it implies that the people of lumiere are real.
Not to mention that using the paintings is objectively beneficial due to time dilation. You can use them to effectively extend your life.
Either way, lumiere doesn't work as an escapism allegory and has no grounding in reality.
The ending is also a bit of an artificial dichotomy created for the sake of melodrama.
The gameplay of the game is also highly derivative
All in all, you fags are retards impressed by shallow aesthetics
The story is not mature, and it's nowhere near a 10
>>
>>
File: 1771653421820336m.jpg (79.7 KB)
79.7 KB JPG
>>737049684
Goty doesnt mean anything.
It's given out by game critics at the end of the day. And those guys are not experts on story telling.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: __frieren_fern_and_stark_sousou_no_frieren_and_1_more_drawn_by_nyoro_nyoronyoro000__4ba9940e3b6dca92a4b942c26bf77a8d.jpg (1.1 MB)
1.1 MB JPG
For me it was The Roottrees are Dead, but I liked E33. It's still better than the other games that were nominated, hell, it's better than most of the games that have been called "GOTY" for the past decade.
>>
File: 1754496526405689.png (456.5 KB)
456.5 KB PNG
>>737049684
that's an interesting attempt at English, friend.
>>
>>
File: image.jpg (537 KB)
537 KB JPG
>>737049684
Cope
>>
>>
>>
File: __clea_clair_obscur_expedition_33_drawn_by_niking__3982c5fdc5fcfacbe78403d307d0388b.jpg (881.4 KB)
881.4 KB JPG
>>737051493
>2026 it would have lost
What even has come out this year? Although I'm interested in Pragmata.
>>
>>
File: VersoKneel.png (293.3 KB)
293.3 KB PNG
If you hate this game, you are BROWN. I don't make the rules, but it is what it is
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>737049684
to be goty you just need to be better than the other games released, last year was one of the worst years in video game history.
the nominees:
>KC2 with gay sex and atrocious combat gameplay
>Walking simulator 2
>Some nintendo game
>2 indie shitters
>>
>>737050223
>>737051017
>>737051420
>>737052087
>Timmy posts shit bait and anon instantly fall for it
We have mastered English better then you
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: goodmorning.png (454 KB)
454 KB PNG
>>737049684
>This game not level of being
>>
>>
>>737049684
I just liked that it put so much effort in the music department, I love good music in games. Nier games are some of my most favorite games because of this. Combat is nice as well. It amazes me that you people still seethe to this day. The game is like 8.5/10 but everything else that came out last year was abyssmal dogshit, which is why E33 was unironically GOTY. It's not that hard to comprehend.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>737050284
Trvthnvke
>>737053543
Jews are brown, and indians are being paid to shill this masonic jewish nepo baby garbage, and call anyone who doesn't like it indian.
>>
>>
File: 1770398844673921.png (599 KB)
599 KB PNG
>>737054340
you got almost all the buzzwords in
>>
>>
>>
File: 1775167924157656.jpg (551 KB)
551 KB JPG
>>737052756
>>737049684
Lost to Tainted Grail lmao
>>
>>
File: This is a fishing pole.jpg (16.8 KB)
16.8 KB JPG
Terrible bait OP. Try harder.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>737049684
>This game not GOTY level of being good
This thread is very obviously a false flag, but you are correct. Expedition is not really GotY tier. That said, it might actually have been GotY out of the games that were nominated. My personal GotY was Look Outside, but it wasn't nominated for anything. Silksong won the Steam awards, which is actual real people voting, not industry plants, so Silksong probably deserved the win the most, but I haven't played it or Hollowknight.
>>
>>
>>
File: 1744319266170996.png (212.1 KB)
212.1 KB PNG
>>737058530
>Silksong probably deserved the win the most, but I haven't played it
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
File: 1760547569874082.png (1.9 MB)
1.9 MB PNG
>>737060386
It was the "kino" aspect. The game was cool, that always leads to a disproportionately positive reception. Hype breeds more hype. It's a great game even with its flaws, but I think people who claim not to understand the hype at all are being a little obtuse on purpose or just shitposting.
>>
>>
>>737050284
>The story for this game isn't even good. The first 2 acts are a generic save the world plotline, while the final act is a failed allegory for escapism.
Nobody is talking about the plot when they praise the story. The plot is good, formulaic to some extent but it serves its purpose. When people praise the game's writing they're talking about its emotional resonance, pacing, characters that feel real and flawed, who undergo development and make you care, dialogue which feels conversational and natural.
>>
>>
>>737060230
Those 4 games are great actually. And could easily be argued to be better than Expedition 33. The most recent of them was released 15 years ago though. Not shifting the goalposts, since I'm not the anon you're replying to, just making my own point that you have to go back that far to compare the game negatively. It isn't a flawless game but it is definitely a beacon of light that big budget games with mainstream appeal can still be good, amidst all the shit which plagues that section of the market today.
>>
>>737060830
I love Maelle's fencer gimmick. I would have liked to have seen or heard a little bit about her fencing training at some point though, we heard plenty about her being a courier but nothing about that. Unless it's just something they teach in the Expedition Academy and she's been training there for years.
>>
>>
>>737050284
Either ending is too cruel for what anyone else would have done realistically. The Fading Boy throughout the entire game is constantly complain everyone is ruining his painting by involving themselves for their own reasons rather than caring about his or his world. Just have Alicia leave the painting, unpaint Verso and then hide the damn painting somewhere safe and leave everyone inside it to their own devices.
Instead we're forced to take the scorched Earth approach both ways whether the player likes it or not. Total death resulting in a crippled girl being forced back into reality or a beautiful sustained fantasy with reality bleeding into the Canvas once again gradually.
>>
>>
>>737066714
>Instead we're forced to take the scorched Earth approach both ways whether the player likes it or not. Total death resulting in a crippled girl being forced back into reality or a beautiful sustained fantasy with reality bleeding into the Canvas once again gradually.
It's that way because Verso orchestrated it that way. He lied to the Expedition, he discarded his sister's letter to Maelle, he let Gustave die on purpose. He did all of this to bring about the exact circumstances he needed to force his mother out and end everything in his own way on his own terms with no room for compromise. Alicia at least seemed to have hope that Maelle could have been a force for peace, wielding the power to sway the fight between two weakened painters in either direction and thus being in a position to insist upon a diplomatic resolution. We will never know how A Life to Dream may have played out because Verso's obstinacy deprived us of that ending.
>>
>>737066714
>Just have Alicia leave the painting
She won't. Also the fading boy is miserable because he never wanted to spend his whole existence painting, his family playing with him made it tolerable but they're gone. There's no good end for verso's soul except oblivion.
>>
>>
File: Fucking retarded faggot.png (218.3 KB)
218.3 KB PNG
>Weebs are STILL seething
I thought E33 was going to be forgotten, though? Curious!
>>
File: title[1].jpg (76.8 KB)
76.8 KB JPG
I liked it, fuck you.
>>
>>737065124
this is all fine but the peoppe of lumiere are completely sidelined by act 3 and its ridiculous.
lune and sciel are killed and resurrected and find our they are painted and barely react. "oh btw verso wanna fuck?"
>>
>>
File: 1744645531996146.png (120.7 KB)
120.7 KB PNG
>when one falls,we continue
>for those who come after
...
>actually fuck that noise, none of their sacrifices meant anything, TOTAL LUMIERE DEATH, youre le bad and a toxic escapist if you dont want to kill everyone you spent 30+ hours caring about
>>
yup its a cheap asset store flip shovelware game for plebs
movie games aka cutscene simulators will always win GOTY because most gamers lack critical thinking or emotional maturity to not latch onto obsessively to any game that they spent 60+ hours in
actual gameplay, navigation, overworld, combat, storyline and everything is sub par and plebs just praising it for cutscenes . a C tier movie from hollywood has better performances, better acting, better story
>>
>>737067589
This. All of it could have been handled if Verso wasn't such a fucking coward. Gustave's death unironically fucked everything up and made reconciliation impossible, especially once Maelle figures out that Verso intentionally let Renoir kill him because he was afraid...of what exactly, one cannot truly fathom, because all he had to do was tag along with them and gradually reveal the truth at pivotal moments. Alicia gets to see her brother once again and go on a final magical adventure with him to save the day, work through her grief and then fucking leave, Gustave gets to be a big damn hero and saves his world while forcibly ejecting both of the idiot parents out of the painting and everyone is satisfied in the end and he would certainly find a way to convince Maelle/Alicia (Malicia) to leave the painting.
>>
File: 1767720352914361.png (472.8 KB)
472.8 KB PNG
>>737075039
>Gustave's death unironically fucked everything up and made reconciliation impossible
Alicia forgives him immediately
>especially once Maelle figures out that Verso intentionally let Renoir kill him because he was afraid...of what exactly, one cannot truly fathom
He says why in the game
>work through her grief and then fucking leave
She's not willing to leave, just like Aline wasn't
>everyone is happy in the end
Not Verso's soul.
>muh golden route
stick to anime RPGs
>>
>>
File: 1747679984505411.png (24.8 KB)
24.8 KB PNG
>>737075489
Definitely, despite being the bad end, Alicia's ending is 10x more kino.
>>
>>737075576
Verso can get fucked and if Alicia wants to kill herself, that's her choice. He has no business pleading her for death anyway, it was Aline that messed with the canvas to begin with, so he should take his complaints higher up the totem pole.
>>
File: 1767768366193634.png (436.4 KB)
436.4 KB PNG
>>737075685
He did, he had Aline kicked out.
>that's her choice
Nah she's 16, daddy knows best. She'll get over it, so will you anon.
>>
>>
>>
File: 1765262348713662.jpg (296.9 KB)
296.9 KB JPG
>>737076595
>literal slave to an insane woman, painted to be a copy of a man with all of his own will removed, killed by the original
yeah mogged
>aline is the better painter
yet with the entire canvas's chroma at her disposal he still fractures it and locks her in a stalemate, seems like she's some kind of retarded. Based sandfall making an entire game about how women need to listen to men.