Thread #286404109
HomeIndexCatalogAll ThreadsNew ThreadReply
H
Objective ranking of KnK movies:
3 > 5 > 1 > 7 > 4 > 2 > 9 > 8 > 6 > 9.5 > 6.5
+Showing all 183 replies.
>>
Reminder that the Fortissimo v2 release, with consistent terminology, is out: https://nyaa.si/view/2079423

Also reminder that pic related is today
>>
Killing a disease is a stupid as fuck idea, so that brings 3 down for me.
>>
>>286404142
Shiki can kill anything.
>>
10 times as strong as marijuana
>>
File: 060953726.gif (448.8 KB)
448.8 KB
448.8 KB GIF
>>286404109
>8
>9
>9.5
>6.5
Weren't there only 7 films?
>>
>>286404858
>he doesn't know
>>
Do I still have time to read Tsukihime before the stream
>>
>>286404109
>3 on the top
You just like rape
>>
>>286406293
I like Mamiko Noto.
>>
>>286406066
Depends on how fast you can read.
>>
>>286404109
I liked 9 a lot, I think it was neat how it presented two takes on precognition
>>
>>286404123
>>286404109
Can i watch this as an alone thing or do i have to read Tsukihime before?
>>
>>286404109
Movie 5 is best, paradox spiral is basically perfect
>>
>>286407902
It's perfectly fine as a standalone thing even if there are some references
>>
>>286404858
They made more after, the worst one is just that tomboy and shiki talking for like 35 minutes on a highway.
>>
>>286407988
Pure unfiltered Nasukino is best though.
>>
>>286404123
Strawberry Haagen-Dazs has been acquired.
>>
>>286407902
The novels predate Tsukihime.
>>
I've never seen this and know nothing about it and I'll miss the first hour and a half because of sushi but I'll be there.
>>
>>286404109
It is I, the one with the correct opinion
2 > 5 > 4 > 6 > 9 > The rest in no particular order.
>>
KnK is chuuni dogshit and anyone who likes it is a faggot.
>>
>>286409508
no u
>>
Welp, nothing made any sense so far
>>
>>286409946
I unironically understand paradox spiral more than overlooking view
>>
>>286409974
it's the other way for me (I've seen the movies once, a year ago)
>>
Maybe I shouldn't have made my first viewing a groupwatch...
>>
>>286404109

>
>>
I unironically think the end of Remaining Sense of Pain has some of the best film scoring ever.
>>
I missed the first three hours what's going on
>>
>>286404109
Wait are you going by chronological order or release order? What do you mean by 9.5 and 6.5?
>>
>>286413147
6.5 = recap
9.5 = Extra Chorus
>>
>>286404109
Personally I rank them
7 > 2 > 5 > 3 > 9 > 1 > 10 > 6 > 4 > 8
(release order)
>>
>>286404109
Always thought 3 was greatly overrated and 2 was underrated.
>>
>>286413236
I see, that makes sense
>>
>>286404109
5 > 7 > the rest >>> 6
>>
>>286413400
> disliking Azaka movie
Are you gay ?
>>
>>
>>286413274
What do you like about 2? I think the atmosphere in that one stands out compared to the other movies.
>>
how many times did (you) watch it to understand the movies?
>>
>>286404109
Been a while since I rewatched but...
5>3>4>1>2>8>7>6>9>9.5
7 is the biggest mystery to me I have seen it probably 4-5 times and I don't have any strong opinion about it despite it being so hyped, I think its just okay.
>>
>>286414070
2 has the most tension between Shiki and Kokutou because she's still a serial killer. It makes the entire movie interesting.
Honestly my favorite is a tossup between 7, 2, and 5. I just ordered them that way to be contrarian
>>
the plot of paradox spiral is seriously retarded, even by nasushit standards
>>
>>
>>286404142
anon, appendix surgery is just that.
>>
>>286415126
Shiki is not a serial killer.
>>
>>286415429
>he doesn't understand what's going on
>>
>>286415429
the plot is shaped like a spiral, do you rike it?
>>
6 > 3 >>> the rest
>>
>>286415930
6 was a snoozefest
>>
>>286415126
>serial killer
Serial LARPer more like
>>
File: 150361.jpg (8.9 KB)
8.9 KB
8.9 KB JPG
So, what was the point of this character?
>>
>>286416859
Consequences of loving Touko.
>>
>>286416859
White Male sorcerer that needed to be taken down a peg.
>>
omg it Freiren
>>
>>286417705
That's Rin you degenerate.
>>
This was quite fun, thank you for the stream. Hope to see you all there next week
>>
2nd time watching
I'm not sure if I understand the chronological order of the movies, is it like this?
2 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 5 > 6
>>
>>286414735
Twice overall, but I had to watch Spiral Paradox about 3 times to sort of understand and I still missed stuff like the lock having a different sound or the first Touko cut being the last one which then transitions to the 1st one before Mikiya showed up
>>286415126
I'm fairly certain Shiki never actually kills anyone, she just goons to it
>>
>>286416859
>>286417154
Pretty much this.
>>286418255
Yes, 7 after 6 and 8(or 9? the one with the dude who has the future sight) after 5
>>
>>286418255
It's 2 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 5 > 6 > 7 > Epilogue > 8
>>
>>286418255
Overall yes, besides the flashbacks and timeskips in the movies making the details a bit more complicated.
>>
>>286418255
I thought 6 was before 5 since we see YOROKOBE at the end, but it makes sense if it's a flashback.
>>
>>286418366
The 6th movie's post credits was a flashback to tie back into murder speculation yeah. A lot of the flashbacks happen during other movies or during different times like 5th's flashback happening before 1, 3, and in the middle of 2
>>
What the fuck. I feel like I need to rewatch everything from today's stream just to figure out whats going on.
>>
>>286419013
It happens anon, it happens. I'd recommend focusing on the story before focusing on the nasu insanity
>>
Is there going to be a video with chat up? Kinda wanna re-watch again with chat soon
>>
Discussion got so heated close to the end that I watched nothing of the last movie.
>>
>>286419470
That'd be kino
>>286419486
What type of discussion? The weird perversion discussions? Those were fun, I almost missed the suicide den
>>
>>286419536
No such discussion took place. All that was talked about was of the wholesome sort, I assure you.
But yeah.
>>
>>286419470
I didn't record the chat. If someone else did, feel free to post it.
>>
>>286420568
Ah of course, just like there was no Tsukihime anime to mention
>>
>>
>>286404109
>movies
read the novels nigga
>>
>>286422326
The only thing good about this series is the few action scenes and music, it not the dialogue, characters, or plot. Do not read the book.
>>
>>286422326
>read
NEVEER
>>
>>286424537
>>
>>286422310
Mata ne!
>>
>>286404109
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gu0lykxUkYg
Best ED song
>>
>>286416859
He gave us great doujins with Aoko
>>
>>286424803
>"I was here"
I like this little nigga.
>>
>>286422859
t. got filtered on volume 1
>>
>>286424818
>I was here
>I was inside shiki's tight vagina before cuckutou cuckiya ever could
Lucky bastard
>>
>>286422859
I like the characters and it's genuinely all worth it for Paradox Spiral
>>
>>286404109
>that ranking
Damn, next week is gonna suck.
>>
I forgot I had it bookmarked too
>>
>9 movies
>>
>>286425304
Shiki had a man inside her long before that.
>>
>>286427735
don't forget you dummy
>>
>>286429151
Really like 12
>>
>>286429151
a tenth is coming out this year
>>
>>286424818
And then he respawned in Fuyuki and got adopted by Kerrytsugu.
>>
>>286433814
Ended up checking and Shirou was born a year before Paradox Spiral, but since Enjoy had technically died 6 months before the story started it wouldn't be impossible
>>
which one of these should I pick
>>
>>286436832
10
>>
>>286436832
Man, old melty had so many colors.
>>
>>286436832
well, your post ends in 32, so
>>
>>286404109
>>
>>286440318
Dirty Red...
>>
>>286432350
made me check, fuck you for getting my hopes up
>>
>>286441548
What even is there left to adapt except the weirdly out of character drama CDs or the alt route in the 3rd part where Azaka confronts Fujino instead that Nasu discussed?
>>
>>286441516
RIP anon
>>
>>286444042
Why is Dirty Red so violent?
>>
>>286444418
It's because she hates the color Red as it reminds her of her dirty lazy no good sister with big tits
>>
>>286436832
don't fulfill THE PROPHECY anon
pick something pleasant like 19 or 32 and use F moon.
>>
>>286441548
>>286442021
I thought he was talking about Mahoyo.
>>
>>286444860
Kill all FGCucks.
>>
>>286444860
Based FGChad.
>>
>>286445692
Oh, yeah I guess. Maho is more like a KnK prequel. It's weird though, Touko in KnK is almost a different character from Touko in Mahoyo, but I guess that's about the trilogy we'll never get to see
>>
>>286448986
>but I guess that's about the trilogy we'll never get to see
So it goes.
>>
>>286425304
kek
>>
had to drop out saturday after 4 movies cause i was tired, just watched 5 today. was super confusing but good nonetheless. going to watch 6 across the week and then i shall be ready for saturday to finish the watchalong.
never seen these movies before but always been interested, pretty cool so far.
>>
>>286417705
And here's Fern
>>
>>286408170
>>
>>286454182
Chainsaw man anime whishes it was this cinematic.
>>
>>286453004
Godspeed, anon. 5 takes a few watches until everything clicks. The overall story is fairly simple but it's told in purposefully deceitful way with lots of neat little things that you can't catch unless you know what you're looking for
>>
>>286454472
>5 takes a few watches until everything clicks
It clicked on the first watch for me but I do have the "really good at logic and absolute trash at being a human" brand of autism.
>>
>I turned into a building Rick
>>
>>286453473
frieren sure got feisty
>>
>>286456808
The consequences of being outsold by MahoAko.
>>
>Your origin is worthlessness
It still hurts.
>>
>>286429151
I mean, most of them are 1 hour long, which is the standard length for an episode of a Netflix series nowadays
>>
>>286458301
Most of them are below the required length to even classify as a movie.
>>
>>286454472
>>286454775
Likewise I got it more or less my first watch in terms of timeline and plot but I still miss lot of neat details that were sort of informed by the Nasuverse shit and other movies. A few standout cases
>Araya's first attempts to talk to Shiki were trying to awaken her origin to shortcut his experiment
>Touko hypnotizing Kokutou
>The elevator spinning is shown early
>The click of the door is different between the two doors
I suppose I very much enjoy how subtle the magecraft is in KnK compared to Fate/ and later Nasuworks. Circuits are less obvious and it isn't so noisy visually. Iirc El-Melloi handles magecraft in a similar way at times but it's still more outright wizard shit instead of dickass magi things
>>
>>286458497
Yes no less good
>>286456228
>>286458284
Araya was something else. I'm surprised Nasu got away with the fake priest archetype twice with Araya and Kirei
>>
The more I learn about Nasu and his work the more he resembles the kind of writer I dread turning into.
>>
>>286459630
Nasu's got a solid sense of writing actual plot, but his lore and writing are extremely insular and self-referential. What you should probably fear is the excessive amount of purple prose he likes to use, but as I understand it that's just the Japanese way. I don't think outside of normie-tier fantasy it's possible to write fantasy without turning into Nasu
>>
>>286459630
it's inevitable, don't fight it
>>
>>286404109
They all sucked.
>>
>>286462388
You suck.
>>
>>286453004
Ganbatte!
>>
>>286404109
Good music and animation, but the source material is a pozzed garbage just like every other Nasu's work.
>>
>>286466874
What?
>>
>>286466874
>pozzed
>Nasu regularly talks about women getting raped and abused and doesn't make a comment about it being bad or anything
>Araya's entire suffering engine
Pozzed in what way? Everyone who has some element of pozzed to them in the series is quite literally mentally ill
>>
How does the quality of the release in OP compare to others? The filesizes are quite small.
>>
>>286471327
I don't have a lossless release at hand for comparison, but here's a quick one-frame comparison between Fortissimo and ANE:

ANE: https://files.catbox.moe/cvi8w1.png
Fortissimo: https://files.catbox.moe/oty4rt.png

It's from a high-motion shot, so that's about as bad as the quality gets at worst. The main reason why Fortissimo is half the size of ANE is that HEVC is just that much more efficient.
>>
>>286454182
those ice cream tubs are tiny. So does nasu only write about midgets?
>>
>>286472846
>those ice cream tubs are tiny
Japanese portions
>>
>>286472846
The small size Haagen-Dazs is only 106 ml (3.6 oz)
>>
>>286415930
I enjoyed 6 much more than the rest too. The movies, while amazing, had way little Mana.

>>286454182
Man these things costed a fortune in my country even before Covid hit. I dont think I'll ever get to enjoy one of these.
>>
>>286473852
What cunt has haagen dazs tinies costing a fortune? They're over here in America for like 6 dollars double the size
>>
>>286474686
A 1 litre tub of these costed around 20 dollar equivalents here last I checked back in 2022. Compared to local brands (which probably sell milk solid infused sugar water in the name of ice cream but I digress) for 3 bucks.
>>
>>286474880
Christ anon, sorry from Ameribros to you. Sucks to hear. On the other hand, making your own dessert is not particularly difficult though the exact nature of making haagen dazs eludes me.
>>
>>286473595
Sounds just about right for me. I can get about 4 or slightly more portions out of one 460ml tub. It's crazy to think that someone would eat the whole thing in one sitting.
>>
I started eating Strawberry Haagen-Dasz in 2018 after I watched KNK for the first time
>>
>>286475945
Likewise for me, though 2019. I was more of a Blue Bell enjoyer previously. Expensive though, but the local mall had a kiosk set up
>>
>>286475290
I tried to learn during the Covid lockdown, Every ice cream recipe required an ice cream maker or some sort of fancy freezer and not a 30 year old fridge with minimal features that is miraculously still chugging along because of superior Japanese manufacturing of the 80s.
>>
>>286475945
I should try that. I've got no stream ritual like that.
>>
>>286474686
it's just the brand slapped on unholy mix that is american fast processed foods
>>
>>286474880
The cheap local ice cream is good though.
>>
>>286459630
Don't worry, like most wannabe writers, you'll never in your lifetime become even 1/1000000 as famous as Nasu is
>>
>>286404109
7>5>9>1>2>3>4>6
>>
>>286482309
If we measure fame by either number of readers or money made then I'm already above that fraction, unless Nasu is a billionaire.
>>
>>286482968
lol, sure, post your book
>>
>>286477963
Yeah, modern ice cream is extra effort but making something via baking to get a similar snack like a flan or creme brulee should be achievable for your average anon. Can always have alternatives, though ice cream can be nice. Ideally, not with shit beer.
>>286479966
That's a lot of name brands in America yeah, unfortunate how it is.
>>
>>286474880
For some reason a lot of stuff that's practically bottom shelf in the USA or Japan get marketed as a premium product in Europe, probably because they know people heard about them in hollywood movies and american pop music and shit but don't really know enough about them to know that they are anything but premium.
>>
>>286483996
Shiki was buying those like they were a dollar, but she's also filthy rich. Funny that she lives in a one room apartment then
>>
>>286404109
3 was awful, 1 and 2 were fine. I'll watch the rest eventually.
>>
>>286484394
If you don't shiki is going to cut you.
>>
I generally get most of the series but the thing I still don't understand is how Araya's plan worked.
How exactly would repeating people's deaths over and over open a path to the Root?
>>
>>286487294
You really shouldn't think to hard about it, even if you do you'll find out it was just plot devices with no coherent explanation.
Nasu is only good for the settings and chuuni. His characters and writing are absolutely atrocious, at least in KnK.
The movies are only good for the great score and pretty visuals, they don't have anything else going for them at all.
>>
Okay, if Haagen Daaz is pretty bad then what is a good ice cream brand? I might just buy one for shits and giggles despite temps being in Spring season range.

>>286487294
I can't remember because I last watched films 8 years ago.
>>
>>286487294
The 64 different deaths and the two sides of the building represent the hexagrams and the yin and the yang, making the building an embodiment of the Taiji. By placing Shiki inside the building, Araya would have had Shiki's Taiji inside the Ogawa mansion's Taiji, and he expected this to work (and it might have actually worked?) because reasons I guess.
>>
>>286487294
It has been years since I saw the film but he was probably curious whether the residents of the mansion could achieve enlightenment in his miniature recreation of the samsara like the buddhas of the in-universe real world have done.
>>
>>286487582
I never understood that Taiji scene before today.
Thank you.
>>
>>286487425
Isn't Mikiya missing the eye that's not facing towards the camera in that shot...maybe he thought it would have been weird for Shiki if she had to bring herself like an inch away from the hole where his left eye used to be for the sake of a kiss.
>>
>>286487774
Doesn't he literally say out loud "I was curious to see if there would be any variation if I repeated everything enough times" or something?
>>
>>286488896
Yes, he does. I think it started as an experiment about whether things really were fated to repeat as they always do, since he's like a crestfallen buddhist priest who should not really believe that things are fated to repeat constantly because that's contrary to the tenets of buddhism, and when he became convinced that yes, they are, that's when he decided that he needed Ryougi to open a portal to the Root, to give meaning to everyone's deaths through bearing witness to all of them.
>>
>>286489039
>>286488896
Like a proper buddhist would believe that given enough repetitions of the cycle someone would achieve enlightenment and realize what was going on. But the cycles just kept going and going without anyone ever getting the slightest clue.
>>
>>286427735
Who's the flatter heiress, Ryougi or Akiha?
>>
>>286429151
Save for 5 they are more like OVA episodes rather than real movies. Overlooking View is what, 31 minutes long...

>>286470375
Nasu said in an interview that japanese feminists praised his work for having a lot of strong female characters, but he said he feels kinda awkward about it because almost all of his "strong female characters" job to the male MC's penis. Arcueid? Jobs. Ciel? Jobs. Akiha? Jobs. Saber and Rin? Jobbers.
>>
>>286487582
>>286489039
>>286489057
He originally didn't think he would have needed Ryougi(or maybe he always did, Araya was going after Ryougi even back during Murder Speculation), his infinite suffering farm was about the repeating cycle of death creating some deviation eventually outside of his design that WOULD have allowed him to, by studying and understanding that variance, open a path to the root. When he became a doomed and realized that this wouldn't work, and that Shiki had the MEoDP and her origin, then he did the Taiji shit to try to force himself into the Root using Shiki's already open route (the MEoDP) as he hadn't known about VOID Shiki. It is somewhat an idea that he hoped that constant reincarnation of the soul, given that he kept the brain jars and therefore their "soul" as seen ain't Enjoy, that the enlightenment of the tenants would lead to his own. But Araya, like a typical mage, had too many moving parts in his plan and was flying by the seat of his pants the second he decided to start dealing with unknowns and the incredibly insane like Alba. Of course, Araya probably may have had a chance if he actually tried to earnestly go after the Root without shortcuts given that he's effectively immortal, but I get the sense that the constant reincarnations have really fucked him up
>>
>>286489471
7 is another two hour movie right?
>>286489471
Nasu himself says he's somewhat ashamed that he makes strong women who have weak mentality, which I guess was a bit corrected with Mahoyo, but yeah. He's kind of just got a particular taste in women I guess.
>>
>>286489581
Uh yeah, that one is pretty long too. 6 is also like exactly 60 minutes, I think.

Legends say that he grew up with two older sisters who were kinda domineering, so maybe that's why this scenario of a male MC getting bossed around by two female characters who are stronger than the male MC is at a baseline outside of the Cool Moment Midway Through the Route and Even Cooler Moment During the Finale.
>>
>>286489688
Maybe that's why it's so ubiquitous in his works, I meant to say.
>>
Has anyone else ever felt a similarity in Araya's samsara suffering farm and the plot of the film Dark City (1998)? I won't say more if you haven't seen it, but it's worth a watch and I kept wondering if it's even remotely possible that the Dark City write knew of KNK. Probably not, I guess, because the anime wasn't made yet. But there are similarities.
>>
>>286489794
>I kept wondering if it's even remotely possible that the Dark City write knew of KNK. Probably not, I guess, because the anime wasn't made yet. But there are similarities.
Dark City predates the first KnK chapter by 8 months.
>>
>>286489558
Alba was truly a retard wasting a perfectly good pair of holes like he did.
>>
>>286489471
>Overlooking View is what, 31 minutes long
It's 50 minutes. Most of them are around 1 hour long.
>>
Why did they translate it as "Overlooking View" instead of "Panorama"?
>>
>>286489346
Akiha, Shiki has tits.
>>
>>286492173
Ryougi's so flat that you could use her as an ironing board if you so wanted.
>>
>>286491640
Because it's not a "panorama" at all anon. Also, just read the kanji.
>俯瞰風景
>>
>>286487582
Naruhodo.

Reply to Thread #286404109


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)