Thread #152668237
HomeIndexCatalogAll ThreadsNew ThreadReply
H
What do you think about W.I.T.C.H.?
+Showing all 109 replies.
>>
>>152668237
Elyon best girl
>>
>>152668378
Wrong image sorry
>>
>>152668237
I liked it a lot.
>>
>>152668413
Can we expect a remake somewhere down the line?
>>
>>152668425
There was a new comic, but I don't think there are any plans for a new WITCH cartoon
>>
>>152668448
Of the comic I had no idea, is it any good?
>>
who's bigger?
>>
I wish there was a Ladybug x w.i.t.c.h. crossover
>>152668507
Either way Cornelia is hotter
>>
>>152668466
The first book was okayish, the second was eeeeeeeehhhhhh

You know Will's original love interest Matt? Well the remake introduces him in the first book, and then throws away all the teasing that happened and make room for Will's new love interest who can be best described as a K-Pop boyband reject who basically spends most of the comic being an stuck up asshole to the girls.
>>
>>152668378
I'll admit it, I am usually a corneliafag but damn if Elyon isn't an erotic minx
>>152668563
I hate when authors push their own husbandos into a work
>>
>>152668237
The blonde haired one got blacked by the black girl’s older brother.
Based
>>
>>152668507
Irma, by far.
>>
>>152668466
It look like a webtoon
>>
>>152669208
Is the plot any good?
>>
How powerful are the witch girls compared to other magical girls?
>>
Are the comics or the series better? What will leave me with a better aftertaste once I finish it?
>>
>>152668378
Elyon is definitely the cutest girl
>>
>>152669763
Both are good.They have the opposite problem, cartoon has a slow start and people have mixed feelings about some of the later parts of the comic
>>
File: PDA4tS.jpg (1 MB)
1 MB
1 MB JPG
>>152668237
I like the sequel.
>>
>>152669763
Comic is better at its best.
Cartoon is still pretty good and arguably handles some parts of the arcs it adapts a bit better.
The one thing you might want to know is that the "New Power" arc in the comic is almost like a soft reboot and most people tend not to like the comic past that. The last arc before it reads like a pretty decent ending too.
>Better aftertaste
I'd says Comic(without New Power)>=Cartoon>Comic Ending past New Power
>>
>>152668237
The original comic is objectively better than the show or the new manga. Shame I missed out on the last storytime.
>>
>>152670611
kek if only, that'd be a glorious show
>>
>>152670794
Speaking of which, I dropped the last storytime during the New Power arc. Might pick it back up this year if I'm not too busy.
Probably ought to restart the arc at least.
Would it be better to restart entirely from Arc 1?
I'm worried if I do that I won't get past New Power this time either.
Anyone else ready to take us some of the way if we do a full restart?
>>
>>152668237
cartoon a shit, comic a best, Will a cute
>>
>>152670974
I find Will amazing too, but also Cornelia. The conundrum!
>>
Do you think they are too overpowered?
>>
>>152668378
>>152668387
>>152670231
She even has a peer reviewed paper that says it is so.
>>
>>152670611
It finally updated.
Still no Elyon vaginal, she got her Meridian robe outfit though.
>>
>>152671548
I tried but there is definitely no contest. Elyon is simply too good as a character and as a wife
>>
>>152671655
Still no...
Damn. I am glad I found the old version gallery.
>>
>>152671655
I just finished playing a few weeks ago. What's in the new update?
>>
>>152669763
Comic is great up to the point where Elyon gets the Crown, undoes all her brother's evil, and the brother (apparently) commits suicide by jumping into a bottomless abyss. Writing and art doesn't immediately fall off a cliff at that point but does begin to go slowly downhill.
>>
>>152672048
>Elyon gets the Crown, undoes all her brother's evil, and the brother (apparently) commits suicide by jumping into a bottomless abyss
...The first is from arc 1, the second is from arc 4.
>>
>>152668378
>>152668387
>>152670231
>>152671548
Elyon is a little femcel schizo who sperged out when Will stole her spot. And she's adorable for it. She's a true /co/ girl
>>
>>152672076
You are right. After Elyon becomes omnipotent, big brother is sent to a supposedly unescapable magic jail. From which he (sort of) escapes. I don't want to reveal spoilers here. Then and ONLY then does he jump into the Void.
As I said, once Elyon became Queen I started losing interest and didn't follow things closely. Excuse me.
>>
>>152672305
One of us, one of us!
>>
>>152668378
Genuinely grew to fucking hate her during that readthrough /co/ had for a while there.
I think because some wanted her to replace Will as the leader of WITCH? Was just bizarre to me.
>>
>>152668507
Irma. I like her the most, busty snarky girl is great.
>>
>>152672975
I think that's the reason. She is a royal and higher ranked but Will is the heart of WITCH
>>
>>152673026
While Will isn't my favorite I didn't like how some wanted more Elyon at the expense of her.
>>
>>152673330
I find Will so cute, her confidence issues are also cute
>>
>>152672048
Knowing that originally elyon was going to be some form of fae or death avatar instead of going good is so interesting. I mean that was when the series was more final but kind of interesting that it's implied she was going to be the final big bad.
>>152671685
>>152672885
She is part of the crew and will lead us into a new era
>>
>>152672975
>>152673026
>>152673330
I lead the old w.i.t.c.h read threads and I'm a elyon guy but I never remember that will was always my no 2? I more hate shipped the two not saying elyon needed to replace will but I did say often they did kind of dropped elyon and wish they did more wth her but I'd prefer she be the sixth w.i.t.c.h or evil again.
>>152668574
Elyon is the type to needily want to get approval from someone then also then keep them in a dungeon
>>152673330
>>152673578
What if they just kissed and fought a little?

But yeah I think I only ever mentioned spots myself because it's a canon thing that will lowkey cucked elyon. She took her crush matt, took her magical destiny (from her pov), stole her friends, held a magical conspiracy behind her back, treated her like dead weight.

>Yes this is both from the comic and show

Anyone would want to "replace" her
>>
>>152673729
Frankly mate I got kinda tired of the constant attempt to veer into bringing Elyon back again. I preferred some of the other storylines over the Meridian stuff.
>>
>>152673729
What would be the perfect spot to date Elyon?
>>
>>152668237
>What do you think about W.I.T.C.H.?
Comic good. At least at the beginning. I've not reached the point where the story "reboots" so I can't comment about how badly that went.
Cartoon okay but less interesting.
Remake comic pretty bad, from what I've seen.
>>152668378
This game is pretty boring.
>>
>>152668378
That's not how you spell Irma though.
>>
>>152673942
I mean again I didn't do most of the later arcs but I think she just is the most stand out and part of the og in a way. I do think orube is great though so she alleviate it a bit

I also just think elyon has her popularity even fanart tend to try and bring her in she's basically a major part of the start. Though as I once memed problem with elyon is she's just to op to be around she's like wmd
>>152673996
On the corpses of her enemies, though in reality she probably would like something a bit weird she and the witch girls are basically wiccans. I think their rooms even prove this like tarranee likes beaches and hot areas.
>>
File: IMG_3827.jpg (76.2 KB)
76.2 KB
76.2 KB JPG
>>152668378
>>152668507
Hay lin though wow why did they do this with her when they didn't have to? and didn't this happen more if winx could do it
>>
>>152674334
>On the corpses of her enemies
This only makes the girl more based
>>
>>152674875
She is our glorious queen
>>
>>152668237
Meh.
I watched Winx Club.
W.I.T.C.H. are going to get live action content, don't know if it's a movie or a series.
>>
>>152668519
Makes sense, Marinette is part-Italian.
>>
>>152676016
And half chinese
>>
>>152668448
>>152668466
>>152668563
>>152669208
>>152669220
Out of curiosity, is the reboot comic available as an e-book?
>>
>>152676036
there have been a few threads posting them but think you can find the translated verison on reddit. They don't have official translation of book 2 yet I don't believe
>>
>>152671861
Some Nerissa stuff, Will has a threesome with Cedric and her astral drops clone, some Elyon butt stuff and oral, also Susan gets put on a S&M predicament situation while Cedrick fucks her daughter and daughters clone in another room and that's about it.
>>
To this day, the reveal that Irma's mom, who looks like an adult version of her, was actually her step mom really frustrates me. It was such a weird and largely inconsequential narrative choice.
>>
>>152676253
>It was such a weird and largely inconsequential narrative choice.

There has been a rotation of writers/artists; in addition to the absence of the original creators (Caneppa, Barbucci & Gnone)
>>
>>
File: Irma pits.jpg (841.1 KB)
841.1 KB
841.1 KB JPG
>>
>>152668237
I think I want to smash Irma.
>>
File: Irma 03.png (388.8 KB)
388.8 KB
388.8 KB PNG
>>152676536
>>
>>152672305
>>152672885
>>152675012
>>
>>152676556
Lovingly, of course. It might be a chorus of slapping meat, but there'll be more kisses than Hershey warehouse.
>>
>>
>>152676536
It's Irma and Cornelia for me.
>>
>>152668237
I'm extremely baffled with how they made Matt some sort of plane walker secret agent of Oracle that worked with them all along. Extremely weak retcon
>>
>>152668237
I feel kind of lonely in liking Hay Lin best and not liking Irma much. Cornelia would be fine too if not for her tragic Caleb romance
>>
>>152677072
Only watched the cartoon and read start of the comics. What happened there with Matt, I thought comics had him as a regular guy and him gaining powers was cartoon thing

Anyway, cartoon had good idea for him and Caleb to broaden the audience. Caleb was the cool rebel leader every boy wanted to be, and Matt was what a boy should be and got rewarded for hardship with getting cooler
>>
>>152677072
I agree, they were better as normal humans
>>
>>152668237

Highly satanic show. They should be stoned to DEATH
>>
>>152677400
Why are you looking for the devil when you should be looking for Jesus?
>>
>>152674334
>wiccans
They all feel surprisingly wiccans. Do they have some basis in reality then?
>>
>>152677076
Hay Lin is my favorite as well.
>>152676452
Meant to be a floating fat girl
>>
>>152677400
You're rapidly helping me to abandon Christ, since apparently everything good is Satanic.
>>
>>152677722
This. I'd rather follow the wiccan like the witch girls than whatever bland biblical shit christians preach.
>>
>>152677400
lol no, the cartoon is full of Christian values
>all three main villains fulfill Satanic archetype in one way or another
>the Oracle's characteristic is pretty close to Jesus
>enemies fueled by hatred, rage, etc you defeat by not fuelling them with negative emotions
>showing kindness toward enemy mooks makes them change sides
>so does exposing how evil their bosses are
>>
>>152678286
I thought it was wicca!
>>
>>152669453
Definitely far stronger than the average magical girl but not Sailor Moon level
>>
>>152676618
Honestly she's not wrong what's wrong with us?
>>152677459
Oh definitely, think i'd almost have liked a weird reboot like that. Like the 00s and 05s when they rebooted old series as edgy or more apathetic gothic imagine that was the new w.i.t.c.h reboot style instead of cutesy kpop and fakime.

Also think they do have basis since they each connect with element in own way, only thing they don't do is talk about being wiccans all day and use a bunch of cryst.......OH NO THE HEART OF KHANDRAKAR they are filthy crystal loving wiccan girls
>>152677547
I feel like you are the anon from the bad end w.i.t.c.h au stuff
>>
TL;DR about the Elyon want to replace Will / Elyon becomes Evil thing?
>>
>>152679294
>they are filthy crystal loving wiccan girls
Do they...prance around naked while "connecting to the Earth? Asking for a friend of course
>>
>>152668237
Neat show. That opening for the cartoon rocks to this day.

Super pissed the digital version is no longer a thing before i could get the whole of the Elyon saga.

>>152668378
Best girl.
>>
>>152668378
She truly is the best one
>>
>>152679380
Nope, only one of them got a crystal that turns them into fairies through a generic magical girl transformation sequence.
>>
Hay Lin doesn't wear panties
>>
How would your teenager selves interact with the characters?
>>
>>152679316
Normal elyon thing
>I was the storytime anon for meridan and start of nerissa arc
>I'm a elyon fan, I kind of teased about wanting elyon to stay evil
>An then people found a bunch of lore and side info on elyon
>most of the meridan arc stuff turns into discussion about wanting elyon to stay evil and wishing disney didn't mess with creators
>then we discussed the concept of her being the 6th witch
>So a bit more of a play on elyon getting her role stolen by will but I don't think anyone genuinely wanted elyon to replace will
>Both are my faves but this is as far as I know though their was more elyon simping and discussion in later storytimes apparently but I wasn't always around in those

Evil queen elyon
>Basically me and another anon had remembered some old lore about elyon having used to be a more evil
>So we did digging for stuff like old concepts and information from old creator interviews and art books
>Found out not only was elyon meant to stay evil
>She was apparently meant to be the main antagonist in first draft
>She even was going to be a more fae/in human kind of avatar of darkness/death
>So kind of a more creepy evil elyon
>This sparked a au of elyon staying evil or being more evil
>Then we had a few threads about it
>I wrote the basic concept for au their were two branching concepts
>1. where elyon became queen of /co/ and meridan and basically was a immortal goddess, who defeated the witch squad. An somehow they come from present to have to stop dictator/eternal queen elyon
>2. was another anons more of a cold war where elyon absorbs phobos instead and still wants to rule meridan. An she basically is fighting the witch girls but ruling as a dark empress
>both were fun and got some stuff
>>
File: wdytwa.jpg (66.6 KB)
66.6 KB
66.6 KB JPG
>>152679903
>your teenager selves
>>
>>152679380
They kind of do all they need to do now is have a naked blood ritual to awaken their inner power
>>152679887
Truly peak, why hay lin best girl. I like to imagine this is just her real self she goes commando often she likes the breeze
>>
>>152679887
>>152680311
>>152677076
>>152676663
She is in her normal outfit in >>152674711
Though. Like why would they do thwt though and if it was allowed why didn't happen as often as it did in winx? Some also think its funny since hay lin is the youngest
>>
>>152680019
I remember those threads, had fun generating AI slop in those.
>>
Poor Hay Lin.
>>
>>
>>152681550
>>152681599
Context.
>>
>>152682367
First image is Hay Lin being repeatedly harassed during the Ragorlang arc, 'infected' with the ragorlang (and having nightmares about it).
Second is a nightmare she has after moving houses.
>>
>>152681599
How much nudity there is in the comic?
>>
>>152680968
I do remember that, I appreciate he was a chiller ai bro and didn't overly spam

Also yep good stuff wild but good
>>
>>152679887
>>152674711
Also how snd why would someone know this? I really don't think its true but I can't tell or why they'd say that cause that would be crazy hidden detail joke
>>
Is it me or did anyone else found Will's mom hot?
>>
>>152677034
Will and Irma for me but Cornelia is a close second, either way those 3 are on a complete different level them the rest. Each one is great and every pairing is really good too. Tbf Will x Irma shipping isn't as deep as the other 2 combinations but it is hot af.
>>
>>152683988
I mean yeah practically every woman in this show was hot
>>
>>152683988
Half the scenes in the game have you fucking her. I wonder why.
>>
>>152684448
Even the principal?
>>152685089
What game?
>>
>>
>>152685230
Witch Hunter
by Lazy Tarts
>>
>>152686337
Are these new alts? or fanart? also really love the sporty will vibe but why did they skip elyon since she's the main focus
>>
>>152686337
Why are they older? Also is there any way to play the flash games?
>>152685871
Who's the chick talking Caleb?

Reply to Thread #152668237


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)