Thread #108281623
HomeIndexCatalogAll ThreadsNew ThreadReply
H
Which controller is best to buy? Xbox, PlayStation, or third party?
+Showing all 94 replies.
>>
>>108281623
Gamesir, 8bitdo
>>
>>108281623
Depends what type of games you are playing. FPS vidya and perhaps racing need the most ergonomic designs and most precision, you don't want any cobtroller. XB controller is the most viable for these, or something else what matches its shape and concave precise sticks.
But for whatever else any cheap 8bitdo or gamesir is fine.
>>
File: espro.jpg (87.3 KB)
87.3 KB
87.3 KB JPG
>>108281623
Gulikit ES PRO
>>
>>108281713
I've grown to hate the official Xbox controllers as they automatically turn off after 5 mins and there is no way to disable it like every other controller.
>>
I bought an 8bitdo and it's not as good as the 360 controller it replaced. 360 controller is the goat thumbwheel controller.
>muh stick drift
imagined zoomer problem
>>
>>108281735
Never experienced anything like that.
>>
>>108281735
Used it plugged in disables sleep mode.
>>
I soldered a new R shoulder button on my xbox360. It doesn't work now, including the B, X and Y buttons. Can someone show me a schematic or a video of soneone doing the same thing?
>>
Xbox have the sticks in the wrong position.
Playstation have 20% of the battery life of the competitors but are otherwise the best.
8bitdo hire shill farms to tell you to buy them but are maybe worth buying on deep sales.
Nintendo are too small.

Hori Fighting commander remains my favourite controller, I don't even play fighting games.
>>
>>108281726
based
>>
I'd love an xbawks controller but with PS layout, two analogs on the botton and dpad on top.
>>
>>108281623
ive never played a controllers game in my life but this thing looks pretty sick i might get one and then do it
>>
Pretty sure xbox has more support out of the box and way longer battery life if you want to go wireless. My experience with playstation 5 controllers is the sticks go bad after about 2 years or so. Haven't had that yet with xbox.
>>
>>108281623
First party:
>Dual Sense
>Steam Controller 2
3rd Party:
>Gulikit
>8bitdo
Avoid:
>Xbox
>Nintendo
>>
I bought a gamesir g7 pro
It's pretty nice, however I haven't used a controller in like 20 years
>>
>>108281623
Supposedly third party. I was reading somewhere that Sony's PS5 sticks break down after like, 500 hours but no name Hall effect Joysticks don't for like, 10K or some shit.
>>
>>108282144
>t.coping snoy
the xbox controller is the best on the market
>>
>>108282419
>the xbox controller is the best on the market
It's not. It doesn't even have Gyro. I play all single player first person games with Gyro assistance. It's also great for Switch Emulationl.
>>
>>108282220
>I was reading somewhere that Sony's PS5 sticks break down after like, 500 hours
Mine are fine still after at least 500 hours. Don't know exactly how many.
Stick problems are more to do with how much of a gorilla you are and environment than a single MTBF.
>>
I've gone though three xbox controllers in as many years. I was going to pick up the new Steam controller and give that a shot, but we still don't have any actual launch details.
Probably going to pick up one of these >>108281726 as I've heard good things about them and I like the xbox layout more than the playstation layout.
>>
>>108281623
Third party. Flydigi Vader 5, just make sure to put some thin pads behind the paddles on the back, or so I've heard.
>>
>>108282542
>I've gone though three xbox controllers in as many years.

Learn how to fix your shit. I've used 3 controllers in 20 years, and 2 of them are still working (360 launch date which eventually had the should button die on an IC level, then another 360 pad that still works, but got a series x controller when it came out and still rocking that).

The Gulikit ES Pro looks nice though, especially with the 30€ price.

>>108282552
I had a flydigi, they are overrated garbage.

>>108282444
>I play all single player first person games with Gyro assistance.
lmfao
>>
>>108281623
>>
>>108282220
>Hall effect when TMR exists
Just get a TMR modded DualSense.
>>
If the switch pro controller was xinput I would use that. But it's not, so I use an Xbox controller.
>>
Logitech F310 or F710
>>
>>108282220
Stick issues are from gorilla nigger behavior and bad batches. There's nothing wrong with the tech. Don't let chink merchants upsell you on crazy shit that also breaks in a few years.
>>
dual sense edge
steam controller 2
hori steam pad
>>
>>108285098
>>dual sense edge
>less than half the battery size of a normal dualsense
no tnx
>>
>>108285115
yeah it’s 1000% it’s biggest weakness
it lasts about 8 hours which is pretty much a super long play season so you have to remember to charge it every time you use it
>>
Every controller just has rubber that deteriorates on the sticks. Has this been fixed yet?
>>
>>108281623
I don't really play games anymore but unless things have significantly changed recently then all 3rd party controllers are pretty much dogshit compared to first party ones. I remember people raving about a particular Logitech game controller so I decided to get one of those and the feel of the d-pad and stick were both the worst I had ever experienced. I would stick to buying either Sony or MS depending on what fits your hand better, Nintendo's pro controller should be fine too. UNLESS of course you can't afford to pay their jew prices then I dunno, go with what the other anons suggested I guess.
>>
>>108281623
I will die before I replace my dualshock 3. Works on linux out of the box wired and wireless, anything else is a meme.
But let me guess, you need more?
>>
I wish there'd be a proper PC controller with the Dualshock/sense layout
Miss me with the asymmetric bullshit
>>
>>108285194
Just swap the rubber tops?
>>
>>108281623
gamesaar cyclone 2
>>
>>108285165
I thought 8 hours was the original Dualsense. My Edge lasts 4, even with the rumble and gimmicks off, which gives it the obnoxious privilege of being the only controller I've ever used that can die mid-session from a full charge. I'd swap in a larger battery if I could, but the internal space is mostly used up as is.
>>
>>108285373
>8 hours was the original Dualsense. My Edge lasts 4
This is correct.
>>
>>108282552
To elaborate on that, Vader 5's paddles are similar to something like the Dualsense Edge's, except there's nothing stopping you from pushing well past how far they need to go, and the internal mechanism for actuation uses a thin piece of plastic that isn't built for that kind of stress.
>>
>>108281992

The original Steam controller was excellent, the only negatives it had were no second stick and no dpad. Well that plus the batteries were a pain in the ass to get out sometimes. I have four, though I did break the right bumper on one of them.

Given that the new one has those (and two more back buttons) and uses a rechargeable battery it should be amazing, once it actually comes out lol.
>>
>>108281623
I bought a GameSir (hate that name) Tegenaria Lite and I'm quite happy. Cheap, low latency, wired, PlayStation layout, just what I wanted.
>>
>>108281623
>>
which controller would make me feel the most like a little baby faggot while i play video games
>>
>>108288540
Wiimote
>>
>>108288575
yes that is definitely some gay baby faggot crap thank you
>>
>>108288540
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJy19UGUnq0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ejdky_oLgy8
>>
>>108288612
jesus christ what a baby faggot
>>
>>108281623
Modern:
>Sony DualSense

Retro:
>8BitDo M30
>>
I like my dualsense, but I realize I will eventually have to replace the joys
>>
>>108283335
Even if TMR is better than Hall, it's a minute difference, not the huge leap in reliability that is moving from potentiometer to Hall.
>>
>>108285302
Seconding this. I did the needful and im very pleased with it.
>>
>Gamesir
>>
>>108290409
Huge difference in resolution though.
>>
File: controls.jpg (354.9 KB)
354.9 KB
354.9 KB JPG
>>108281623
It depends on which one you used before, I used the Wii classic controller pro so I went with the 8bitdo pro 3. As a logical upgrade.
>>
>>108281630
>gamesaar
good morning!
>>
>>108285273
my ds sticks don't want to come off...
>>
>>108291411
Pull harder.
>>
File: s-l640.jpg (9.2 KB)
9.2 KB
9.2 KB JPG
This one can withstand a lot of underwater pressure, if that's what you need.
>>
File: K9C6Sqz.jpg (509.5 KB)
509.5 KB
509.5 KB JPG
Picked up one of this little fuckers from chinks
Works alright for me
>>
I can't play FPS games with controllers, I feel like a genuine retard when it comes to aiming and moving at the same time. However I played FPS games on competitive level on LANS back in the days.
>>
>>108285273
>>108291411
>>108291416
Kek
>>
>>108291416
Evil
>>
>>108281623
Xbox and Playstation controllers are basically just chinkshit. They're overpriced by 40$ (upwards of 100-150 for "pro" variations) so they can act as deferred cost for the console they're attached to.
Third party will depend on what you're playing. For most games a keyboard and mouse will just be better unless they're designed wrong on purpose or because the laziest option was chosen and the laziest option was designing the controls wrong on purpose due to all the kickbacks that dragon drop engines got from consoles and Microsoft. You probably don't want a generalist controller modeled after any console, those are mostly ewaste, because the designs they're based on are also cheap ewaste.
>>108285194
Your soap is shit, get soaps and hand creams without limonene.
>>108287841
>No second stick
>No Dpad
Those aren't really negatives. The second stick would be useless because most games don't have you control 2 characters at once, the Dpad is not necessary because you aren't using a 2 button SNES controller so you have options on where to bind those directional inputs without running into the misinput problems associated with Dpads.
The negatives of the the Steam controller are as follows
>Rebinding software is kind of shit and necessary
>They caved and added a traditional stick and face button layout in the stupid SNES bottom surgery position, so the buttons and stick aren't ergonomic when paired up with the controller body which was designed entirely around the trackpads and buttons placed in-between those trackpads
>Bumpers are kind of stiff and the flexing battery panels are also stiff
>Due to game control schemes frequently being designed wrong on PC (see previous rant) you can't get the full range of use out of the controller
>>
I love my 8bitdo pro controllers! I have two of those. And I have four dualshock controllers too but all the microusb ports on them are kinda fucky after years of use. And they are all still fairly solid, just worn out; random disconnects if I'm tugging the cable at all. They work perfectly fine wirelessly!
>>
I was never a big console gamer but since I started emulating more games I got a gamesir nova 2 lite, it's nice enough for the price imo but my frame of reference is limited
>>
>>108281992
FUCKING LET ME BUY IT ALREADY GABEN YOU FAT OVERWEIGHT ROUND BULGING MASSIVE TOWERING SUBSTANCIAL LUMPISH INFLATED LARGE IMPOSING MOUNTAINOUS COLOSSAL PLUMP GINORMOUS HUGE MONOLITHIC WALLOPING CYCLOPEAN MEATY CORPULENT MONUMENTAL HULKING BOUNDLESS LEVIATHAN BLUBBERY HUMONGOUS VAST GIGANTESQUE OBESE IMMEASURABLE MONSTROUS VOLUMINOUS IMMENSE PUDGY ELEPHANTINE SIZABLE BROBDINGNAGIAN FLABBY HEAVY OVERSIZED CONSIDERABLE HEFTY BLOATED TUBBY BIG-BONED ROTUND GARGANTUAN WELL-FED LARDWHALE NIGGER
>>
>>108281630
came here to post exactly this

8bitdo ultimate 2 or sn30 pro
gamesir g7
>>
>>108291491
kek
>>
>>108281630
>>108281726
Chink controllers always have some single big flaw though.

>8BitDo
They are great though.
>>
Top 7 controllers according to a nip reviewer who buys all sorts of first party, third party, and modded first party controllers.
>>
>>108281623
Most games only use xbox's glyphs if that bothers you.
>>
This is god tier
>>
>>108281623
I have 2 xbox series x controllers and both got stick drift within 2 years with just moderate use. Never had that happen with any other controller. Wired 360 controller is still working just fine after almost two decades. DualShock 3 controllers never had any problems (just dead batteries now). Didn't have any issues with my nintendo controllers either (knock on wood, I know the joycons are prone to stick drift).

Looking at getting a better controller for PC games (linux) right now and I suppose TMR sticks are the way to go at this point.
>>
>>108292393
>limonene
Mind elaborating about this?
>>
>>108281623
Get a Jew. They control everything.
>>
>>108300007
>limonene
Eats through rubber and some kinds of plastic

>>108300063
Gas jews. Kill all jews. No peace and stability in the world until the last kike is killed.
>>
>>108300007
It's an organic solvent that's in a lot of soaps and other cleaning products. Since it is an organic solvent, that means it will also help dissolve adhesives, oils and some rubbers.
Whether it has an effect will depend a lot on the type of rubber, but natural latex rubber is something that will definitely degrade.
I mostly just avoid it because I wash my hands frequently and it's courteous to not get blood everywhere.
>>
>>108300007
>>108300085
Thanks Anon(s).
>>
>>108300142
And (You) as well.
>>
>>108281623
From personal experience

PS4 controllers are great provided you do yearly maintenance, that way you won't have stick drifts.

Next is PS3 controller because of pressure sensitive buttons. Less ergonomic than PS4 but its ok.

Xbox 360 controllers have horrible Dpad and will give in eventually so worse than PS3 in every way.
>>
8bitdo ultimate 2c is like 20$ on aliexpress rn
>>
>>108301390
It's okay especially for its price. Analogs are always an issue with the cheap controllers but this seems to be fine. I know it's hall effect but this doesn't mean the build quality couldn't be better.
I wouldn't buy this for FPS games, it's not that ergonomic because it has convex and short analog sticks and co troller itself is really small. Plastic also feels like it is really weak and could break any moment. D pad is mushy but still better than many others. Otherwise it's okay.
>>
>>108301504
who tf plays fps on a g*mepad
>>
>>108292827
based
>>
I have an official Xbox one because it just works with windows. Idk if it's a problem anymore but I'd always have to use workarounds and rebind shit with my chink controller
>>
>>108295333
All controllers are chink, there's not a single controller model that's not getting manufactured in china
>>
>>108301832
I think you're missing the point. For example, western / non-Chinese companies manufacturing in China have almost always higher QC standards.
>>
>>108301832
Chink controllers = controllers from chink company not manufacturing plant
>>
>>108301845
>>108301849
Is still a Chinese controller, I don't care if the company was founded 300 years ago in the McDonalds islands and they put a cool looking sticker in it, if it's manufactured in china then is a Chinese controller
>>
>>108301911
retard take
>>
>>108301961
That's how faggots who buy GaymeSAAR cope.
>>
I saw a screenshot of the G7 Pro software (left) only able to bind a single key to a button, while the Cyclone 2 (right) is able to bind up to three at once. Has that changed at any point, or does the more expensive controller seriously have cucked software?
>>
>>108281623
My powera xbox controller gets the job done for anything PSX or newer. I use the 8bitdo M30 Wired for everything else.
>>
>>108281630
good morning

Reply to Thread #108281623


Supported: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, WebM, MP4, MP3 (max 4MB)