No, she shouldn't exist at all. Her entire premise is a clusterfuck that doesn't fit into the show.

>>43065550
your mom said that about you in real life so you share something in common with cozy glow

>>43065553
I knew there's a reason why I hate her.

>>43065546
I feel like Twilight break her out of the stone and attempt to reform her. Celestia did it for Discord. He and aged Fluttershy can be given the task. But this time it fails and she escapes into the Everfree Forest and can be one of the villain threats in G6. Continuing with the same art style and VAs of course.

New main characters can either be the CMC and 3 others, or Flurry Heart and 5 others. Depending on how long you want to go into the future. But the M6 should all still be alive just old and rare screen time and maybe occasional B plotlines with them.

Move creature university to some weird place in Equestria so we never have to see them.

I hope Hasbro reads this board, I think it'd be cool.

>>43065546
Obviously. Hell, she didn't even get one chance to reform. They just straight up tosser her in Tartarus overnight. It simply does not make sense.

>>43065606
I'm sure they will.

File: 1771024772739115.png (924.9 KB)

924.9 KB PNG

>>43065546
She gets one more chance. ONE. She just lacks discipline and humility. Better nip that bullshit in the bud before she grows up to be an insufferable boss bitch.

>>43065546
>Celestia literally says she's going to turn Cozy into stone because she literally cannot think of any crueler way to torment her for eternity
>Discord excitedly joins in
>every character in the show's history is not only cool with it but overjoyed

>>43065913
Almost correct, but the stoning was Discord's idea.

>>43066072
Fuck that's even worse. They really just had to subvert every fucking aspect of every character before the show ended huh?

>>43065546
Needs rape correction

>>43065546
The only people who want to redeem Cozy are pedophiles that want to fuck her. You don't see this level of defense for Tirek, Sombra, or Storm King.

>>43066334
That one tumblr artist who drew reformation stories for all 3 of the statue trio cared about Tirek, but then again she was clearly a Discordfag so that's not really comparable to anons here.

>>43066334
Fully grown adults vs a little kid, very fair comparison. You're either ragebaiting or genuinely slow.

>>43065903
giwtwm

>>43066334
I don't even get why pedophiles like Cozy so much. Most of the time if feels incredibly forced.

>>43066358
You wouldn't care if it was a little colt.

>>43066391
She fills a category that no other character in the show does. Personally I'm not a big fan of Cozy but if someone's the kind of person to want loli villains then they're gonna like her.

>>43066406
>That no other character in the show does
We've had antagonists
We've had fillies
We've even had fillies that were antagonists
She brings nothing new to the show

>>43065546
Did she even have a reason to be evil? Isn't she just a worse version of Jack Horner?

>>43066432
>We've even had fillies that were antagonists
Soft antagonists, sure, but not serious threats. DT isn't a villain she's just a bit of a cunt.

>>43066406
In this way, Haber, Big Jim, and whoever else are truly brilliant trolls. They gave the cunnyfags the exact kind of archetype that panders to them so that they could get attached to it and fantasize about a possible redemption for her, only to tear it away from them and give them the middle finger.

>>43066446
There's always a reason. Sometimes that reason is the writer's desire to subvert expectations by making a reasonless villain. Jack Horner is not even that, his reason is obesity: elevated il-6 drives people crazy.
>>43066334
I'd fuck r63'd Sombra or Tirek. Or both at the same time. Not so sure about the monkey, his design sucks balls.

>>43066495
It reminds me a bit of what Tomino did with ZZ Gundam, adding a loli archetype character named after a popular loli magazine at the time and then making that character suffer as much as humanly possible.

>>43066535
>his reason is obesity
No wonder Twiggie Piggy is such a bitch sometimes!

>>43066334
Wanting to rape a filly doesn't make me a pedophile.

>>43066401
I would, because there both children. The only reason I care is because a little kid wasn't given a real chance while a fully grown woman that once bent reality had 2 or 3. I don't care about the fully grown adults that are literal warlords.

>>43066324
Yea, and making Discord's entire character arc meaningless as well.

>>43066334
>You want this child character to get a better ending, so you must be a pedophile!

>>43066401
I would.

>>43065546
honestly no
she contacted one of the most devastating villains in history specifically for the purpose of repeating what he did on a far larger scale
she was a student of the M6 and learned absolutely nothing from her time there apart from how to better manipulate ponies
she knew perfectly well that her actions would have deadly consequences worldwide and she did it anyway
then Discord taught her friendship and gave her a second chance
even if it was a trap, she still had every opportunity to decide to just not be evil
instead she immediately worked to overthrow the ruling powers
there's really no way that she can be trusted with any sort of freedom, she's proven repeatedly that she will attempt to destroy society in exchange for power
you can't reason with or redeem someone like that
>b-b-but she's a kid
foals are not equivalent to children
EQG shows that the M6 are high school age as humans, but they are functionally adults in Equestria
the friendship school is treated as secondary education but accepts foals alongside young adults
they don't seem to have grades and only minimal restrictions on what foals are able to contribute in society compared to adults
not to mention that Cozy repeatedly shows she's smarter than most adults on the show
>b-b-b-but she doesn't deserve to be stoned for eternity
first off all the M6 were shocked to learn that Discord was aware during his imprisonment, normal ponies aren't
from her perspective no time passes at all
secondly non-lethal imprisonment is the best case scenario
any nation in our world would execute her for treason, child or not

>>43066798
You are incorrect.

>>43066334
... and?

>>43066798
This argument is retarded

>>43066798
>Discord taught her friendship and gave her a second chance
No he didn't.
>she still had every opportunity to decide to just not be evil
No she didn't. By your logic, Discord had every opportunity to rethink his actions while he was petrified and stop being evil, or just stop being evil when he escaped.
>foals are not equivalent to children
Yes they are. EQG ages are clearly different.
>Cozy repeatedly shows she's smarter than most adults on the show
Not really.
>any nation in our world would execute her for treason, child or not
Nope.

>>43066798
>normal ponies aren't conscious in stone
That's a lie. It's propaganda actually. Celestia literally said she wanted to torture them.

>>43065546
No

>>43067819
>By your logic, Discord had every opportunity to rethink his actions while he was petrified and stop being evil
what new information was shown to him while he was petrified?
fucking nothing
Discord was the same person before and after imprisonment
Cozy was taught friendship in the school, then she was taught friendship by "Grogar", and they even made a point of showing the lessons sinking in, but she still chose to be far more evil than Discord was ever shown to be

>>43068525
He had all that time to contemplate. Heck, even after he was released, he kept going back to doing horrible shit. Why did he just not do that?

As for Cozy, the school was not a rehabilitation program and Discord was never teaching the trio friendship. He was just using them for his prank. Discord constantly did more bad things then Cozy. And heck, you want new information? What about being forced in a cage next to a 1000 year old supervillain, then being made to work with 2 old ass supervillains, who no doubt had quite the negative effect on a growing filly brain.

Cozy, simply put, misunderstood her lessons, no attempt was made to correct them, then was systematically placed in the kind of company that would make a child worse.

File: 2247168.png (1.1 MB)

1.1 MB PNG

>>43065546
Yes

>>43068336
Faggot

>>43069385
>that image
Hell yeah! That's what I like to see.

>>43066324
Writers probably thought
>Wouldnt it be funny if discord suggests the trio turn to stone like he was
And we went back to the esoteric punishments that fit more with ancient equestria and not FIM Equestria.

>>43065546
No. She's a shit "character" from a shit season who shouldn't exist

File: maxresdefault (1).jpg (96.2 KB)

96.2 KB JPG

>>43065546
Her problem lies in her anger. Nice little ponies don't get angry and it's her fear of this 'forbidden emotion' that turns her evil instead. The anger becomes something far more sinister.
A reformed Cozy would be constantly grumpy.