>>129965506
Queen is underrated, it’s just the greatest hits people overhype.
Just listen to their first 3 albums and you’ll understand what I mean.

File: 190919.jpg (105.1 KB)

105.1 KB JPG

>>129965636
general public say queen as one of the greatest bands ever but just regard the hits, here they are not really underrated
music nerd circles online definitely put them as overrated or 'not that good' but still with some great iconic songs
idk if it's correct to say they are underrated honestly

>>129965506
Roger Waters is a woke talentless hack, and I'm tired of pretending he's not.

>>129965683
Nice try bibi

File: 110943.jpg (104.2 KB)

104.2 KB JPG

>>129965683
>woke talentless hack
care to elaborate on this? would you mind if i demand some proof of this?
this is a strong statement anon, you can't just say this on an iconic musician with no evidence

File: Talentless Rog.png (153.5 KB)

153.5 KB PNG

>>129965734

File: Roger the feminazi.jpg (39.6 KB)

39.6 KB JPG

>>129965695
Rent free, tranny.
>>129965734
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLssKrCr9J4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ScJrkh5aWt4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fV9QEkdYtE4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75lk2cQzggc
There are faggots here who still think he's heckin "le based."

>>129965796
Good goy

>>129965796
damn wow woke claims oh wow big ego shit oh damn woooow i kinda dont give a fuck lol he is still great

File: soyjak-angry.gif (82.4 KB)

82.4 KB GIF

>>129965816
>>129965859
>REEEEE STOP TALKING SHIT ABOUT MY FAVORITE ANTI-WHITE AND LGBTQ FRIENDLY MUSICIAN YOU FUCKING CHUD! ROGER FUCKING WATERS IS MY GOD!
Kill yourselves.

>>129965979
why are you portraying me as the whiny söyjak when it's you who is whining lol
notice how i didn't even imply any of these statements you claim i did
you can talk shit fine anon just don't act like a lil bitch when others don't agree or don't care about your whining

>>129965506
>the beatles are good
Careful, you’ll summon him

>>129966449
i want him here!

>>129966815
Notice how there's a mountain of Beatles spam and he's not there for any of it. Boybandhomo's having an extended melty that hopefully ends in his filmed suicide

>>129965683
Roger Waters is a woke talented genius

>>129965796
omg he criticized blumpf, the nerve!

Hard Rock is what music is all about. I only like prog/metal/punk/whatever when it resembles hard rock
Aerosmith is awesome

rock, hip hop, and country are crass music for children, teenagers, and working class brutes lacking refinement. r&b, electronic music, and jazz are unironically superior

>>129967602
(You) are God's strongest pseud

>>129967608
A tough title to hold, even years after the Pitchfork fellating ended

Not as controversial, but AOR style production sucks due to it sounds too sterile

>>129965506
There's nothing wrong with liking RYM top music, just because something is obscure or lesser known doesn't make it better.

>>129967580
based rockist
what's your fav band & album from each of these genres?
>>129967602
cringe pseudo-elitist
name me 7 (seven) underrated r&b and jazz artists

File: 1041452.jpg (55.7 KB)

55.7 KB JPG

>>129968140
>nothing wrong with liking RYM top music
what a brave yet controversial statement!! God bless you anon!

>>129965506
(1/2)
first wave anarcho punk is shrill tuneless nonsense known more for its inane message than having actual musical quality

Tony Martin-era Black Sabbath has no hooks. Martin can sing and hold his own definitely, Iommi wasn't interested in writing memorable songs and the only Tony Martin worth considering is Forbidden which is widely considered their worst

ska blows. reggae is good.

Nirvana's impact on music is grossly overstated and their only purpose was to bring Seattle to the masses, they're not bad from a musical standpoint by a longshot, but Melvins, Tad, Soundgarden, U-Men, Skin Yard and Mudhoney were better bands. not Pearl Jam though. fuck Pearl Jam.

I no longer hold this opinion but when I first heard Acid Bath I though who put Creed in my Eyehategod and got dogpiled for thinking this. I have more nuance now but yeah, first impressions

The Deftones' influences are more interesting than The Deftones themselves

The Who didn't get good until Who's Next.

The Manic Street Preachers are corny and goofy sounding. they're also preachy as hell. shut up and play music, retard.

most people in the music biz who criticized Limp Bizkit (aside from Seth Putnam) really missed the whole point.

Rage Against The Machine's entire shtick is doing the opposite of whatever any random nobody in Alabama is doing

Washington D.C.'s Void and Milwaukee, WA's Die Kreuzen don't nearly get enough credit for anticipating the metal crossover

>>129968508
(2/2)

The Peter Gabriel versus Phil Collins debate is bunk considering both contributed to each others' works and its really just a matter of personal opinion

Vivaldi is probably the most overrated composer of the baroque era and is entry level orchestral music at best

I Don't think R Kelly fans nor Michael Jackson fans care about their alleged (or otherwise) transgressions and continue to listen to their music unabated

more of a conspiracy theory but Revolution Summer was a ploy by the Central Intelligence Agency to weaken hardcore from within (because a lot of D.C. hardcore kids had parents in the local government) and turn the movement inside out

>>129965506
>>gen alpha will create better and more iconic music than gen z
What music did gen z evem create to begin with

>>129968508
>The Who didn't get good until Who's Next.
I'd argue The Who Sell Out

We might need around 100 more years for people to really see how groundbreaking and genius Korns music* was.

*first 4 albums

Roots rock > progressive rock

>>129968144
>Prog
Avenged Sevenfold - Nightmare
>Metal
Marilyn Manson - Mechanical Animals
>Punk
The Clash - London Calling
I guess that might not illustrate my point all that well and im using very loose definitions of those terms so ill just say I like buttmetal, heavy prog like rush and melodic hardcore

File: 1529960975681.png (7.6 KB)

7.6 KB PNG

>>129968508
>I no longer hold this opinion but when I first heard Acid Bath I though who put Creed in my Eyehategod and got dogpiled for thinking this. I have more nuance now but yeah, first impressions

You're not wrong for thinking that. I dare classify When the Kite Strings Pop as Nu-Metal. Think I'm crazy? Here's Mike Sanchez in his own words.

>>129969077
heh, no wonder I wasn't a huge fan of them.

File: 510362.jpg (64.8 KB)

64.8 KB JPG

>>129968508
>The Deftones' influences are more interesting than The Deftones themselves
from all your takes this is the only one that baffles me
like, no, you're very wrong, what makes you believe such non-sense

>>129969104
Shudder To Think, Bad Brains, My Bloody Valentine, Suicidal Tendencies > The Deftones.

>>129968529
isn't Sabrina Carpenter Gen Z? they seem to be a pop diva factory.

File: Pol_Pot_(cropped).jpg (30.4 KB)

30.4 KB JPG

>>129967602
intellectuals belong in a ditch

>>129965506
RHCP is a great band.
Early Floyd up to Meddle was their best.
Early Nick Cave up to Henry's Dream was his best.
Sgt. Pepper is in fact the best Beatles album. Abbey Road and Revolver (and especially rubber Soul on /mu/) have gotten considerably overrated.
Springsteen is actually a GOAT and deserved all his praise. All millennial and zoomer criticism of him is stupid.

>>129968508
My impression with Acid Bath has not changed, they're a watered down version of their contemporaries.

Also agreed with all your take except the Michael Jackson part as the judged has already ruled him as innocent.

>>129965506
ITAOTS is a boring meme album.
The only good Narbaner album is Bleach.
Modernism and Post-Modernism solved Classical.
Saucerful is the best Floyd album.
Popsharters should have their own separate board.

>>129969346
Classical music died when the Romantic-era ceased. There's no such thing as "modernism/post-modernism" because it's just random technical bullshit composed by pretentious hack that doesn't sound good in practice.

File: 224943.jpg (246.3 KB)

246.3 KB JPG

>>129969346
>ITAOTS is a boring meme album.
screw you it's a pretty good album, it became a meme for a reason
you're simply tired of it and its reputation as THE /mu/core album makes you cringe but you should see beyond all that shit
you cannot deny its influence and THE FEELS it provokes and how fucking good it is

>>129968518
>Vivaldi is probably the most overrated composer of the baroque era and is entry level orchestral music at best
I appreciate the nature of the thread but this is a colossally stupid opinion. I've read so many variations of "Vivaldi wrote the same violin concerto 50 times", or "it's just pop music", and it doesn't reveal anything but the lack of real musical knowledge from the speaker. Bach himself wrote nine Vivaldi transcriptions, and along with Handel he is by far the contemporary composer with whom he engaged the most. As a melody writer, and particularly in melodic development, Vivaldi is in the absolute top tier. Even structurally, sure he's not Bach but not all his works are the four seasons.

Is this 'entry-level music'?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AewmWwY08RI

>>129965506
The Beatles, starting from their second half of their career, is indeed the greatest of all time. Thanks primarily to George Martin and with years of experiences spent working with the fab four, he refined their sound and learned how to work around the musicians' limitations, which resulted in some of what I call the greatest albums ever produced. His approach to production, experimentation and pushing the boundaries of pop music of that time can't be understated. The Beatles deserved that title and the reason why I think this is a controversial opinion is the internet has made it cool to mock and overrate the band but can never articulate why they think it's so.

But fuck Let It Be because Phil Spector is a talentless hack.

>>129969439
No one cares romantictranny. Minimalism GODS, electric chuds, spectralist chads, and serialist bros mog your traditional snoozefests.

File: MV5BY2YzMzlkYjQtOTY0Yy00OTA1LWI2NjMtYjhiMzJkMjc2MDZkXkEyXkFqcGc@._V1_.jpg (630.5 KB)

630.5 KB JPG

>>129965506
I think anco is one of the greatest musical group of my generation. The lowest score I've gave their album on RYM is 4* and this can't be said with other artists I've engaged with.

>>129969597
Phil Spector was amazing up through 1966, but after that his talent seemed to evaporate

>>129969456
It influenced the "stomp clap hey" 15 years later and therefore it's a net-negative to society

>>129969627
wow okay now you're just pissing me off with this shit
nah i am done with you

>>129965506
Lo-fi black metal production sucks. Gorgoroth perfected how black metal should sound, a complete satanic sonic assault to your senses.

>>129969717
>Lo-fi black metal production sucks
i mean you're correct but this take wouldn't constroversial at all among everyone who don't listen to black metal, that shit fucking sucks honestly

>>129969613
not controversial in music nerd circles

>>129965506
music will be fine, despite your continual comlpaining

File: 4223650014664192.gif (339.5 KB)

339.5 KB GIF

>>129970629
wrong
music will die and perish and get forgotten
music will cease to exist music will be extinguished music will be gone forever

>>129965506
>>129965734
>>129969456
When was the last time you posted your coords to /cgl/, nonny?

>>129969613
sososo good i hate how they arent really mentioned now
also what album did you give a 4

>>129972027
kys

>>129974990
No thanks. Also rude

>>129965506
Not controversial but I'll fuck your pussy