>>220471174 I think Sara is hot but she definitely deserved it. >killed Kenny's dad >killed her own brother >killed that Terry or Tobey or whatever the fuck his name is >tried to kill Ethan She 100% deserves it. It just goes to show that even in some crazy pocket dimension with monsters, pussy privelege still reigns supreme. >guy becomes alcoholic due to the pressures of living amongst monsters in some crazy world >gets drunk and passes out >his retarded daughter opens a window and gets her and her mother killed >somehow it's the father's fault the kid is retarded and is thrown in a box >Sara goes on a 3 kill streak and gets a UAV >doesn't go in the box Women truly live on super cupcake easy mode.
>>220471363 don't forget how Elgin gets tricked into just temporarily kidnapping Fatima, like no one died or got hurt from it, and he's brutally tortured and threatened to keep his mouth shut or Boyd will fucking murder him. I know lots of people hate Elgin but he doesn't deserve this shit when a repeat murderer like Sara is allowed to walk around town freely.
>>220471403 Nah you lost me with that one. I give Sara a pass for that simply for the fact that Boyd gave her the pass to do whatever to find his "daughter in law". He clearly was okay with whatever needed to happen so they could find Fatima. But it does goes to show how retarded they made the characters >Elgin gets tricked into kidnapping Fatima and stealing her baby >Sara tortures the absolute fuck out of fat ass to find Fatima >Sara starts hearing voices again >fat fuck retard tells her to listen to them, even though he literally did the same, kidnapped someone for no reason and got tortured for it On what fucking planet does this shit makes sense? Why is this stupid fat piece of shit so fucking retarded? And the cherry on top is >this stupid fuck Sara listens and does what it says >even though she's done this song and dance and it went terribly last time with 3 ppl being killed, including her own brother
>>220471363 I laughed in season 1 when Tabitha was all weirded out by Ethan hanging out with Victor, but then was perfectly fine with him hanging out with Sara who then tried to kill him. Very accurate representation of the double standards people have against men nowadays honestly, based show
>>220471466 Sara was just concerned about Sophia getting hurt. Elgin is retarded though yeah. But honestly it’s consistent. He never acknowledged he was in the wrong for listening to the kimono girl, maybe he still trusts her like a retard.
>>220472591 >>220472641 >>220472690 I'm pretty sure the box will be relevant in this season because remember when MiY arrived in the city? He strafed the box with the car before hitting the wall of the post office. They even did an extra shot of this part and showed it again in the recap next episode.
I recall reading either her on a forum that the whole thing is a game they have to play by the rules and the more they try to break those rules the worse the game gets in order to balance itself... just like some people theorized that fairy tales were actually used to caution and warn others of the dangers, could it be that everyone brought in Fromville has some kind of fairy tale or nursery rhyme that could help them deal with the "game"? Like Fatima's goym crafting for example
This show reminds me of Alan Wake. No one behaves like an actual person would behave, shit just appears and disappears, nothing really makes sense, and in the end it all means nothing.
>>220474475 imagine if this show is just a big teaser for Alan Wake 3 or the plot twist is someone is writing the story as it goes in his room and it's all just a book.
>>220475118 from what we've seen so far Julie somehow can't save anyone who's already been killed by the monsters. Boyd wasn't immediately threatened by anything, only dehydration and starvation, so she threw him a rope, apparently that's allowed. Those are the "rules" apparently.
This show is absolute fucking trash. muh feelinz. It's like movies and TV shows no longer just tell a story. They're all trying to brainwash and gas light you into how you SHOULD feel and think and react to the dumbest fucking shit and situations; literally making retarded, automation drones and biological hardware. Every moron watching this slop is going to be acting, reacting and speaking the way these retardedly written characters do in this show. It's nauseating
>>220471403 It is a depiction is how people on general have control issues and always want to tell others what to do and feel. They can't mind their fucking business and leave others the fuck alone. This is why I hate people. If anything, this show depicts how the average moron in society behaves and it did a good job at showing that. I treat people like natural disasters—prepare and protect myself, because they are always coming with some bullshit and trying to force themselves on you
>>220475194 >that rare person who understands time travel paradoxes >>220475118 She already saved him so there was no issue. She didn't save Jim though. Thus, she can't stop miy from killing him. If she succeeded it would be a perfect example of the time traveler's paradox. (But Jim will probably be back in some form anyway as more than just an occasional ghost)
>>220474784 >>220475175 >>220475255 it might look as wig because before cut the hair was heavier, pulling down, and now without much weight it looks more voluminous hiding the hair line
>>220471069 Finally, a really interesting episode. I wish I hadn't spoiled the killer scarecrows for myself—they look awesome. I hope this will be the starting point for people to head out into the woods to explore and discover more strange and amazing things.
>>220476632 he tried to do some things initially but then was reluctant because it backfired. Jim tried to protect his family, he's not a lone wolf like jade, who also hasn't done anything for 4 seasons now.
Also he literally dug a massive crater in the basement with a shovel, that's hard work.
>>220476900 this is from s3ep1. grandma simply enters a warded house because the door was opened. Small correction, Boyd didn't see this, he was in the barn when he put the talisman on but they were already inside. So it didn't work then but it's a bit iffy on the rules.
>>220477312 Ok, changing the subject. How about the magic worms that cleanly and fully transferred themselves into a dried out corpse and killed it (only for a bit)? And why were the worm infected guys being immortal and tortured forever instead of getting killed like the rest? If these worms were such a repellent why were they never brought up again?
>>220475585 miranda would have met miy but not been aware he was eating people because she was dead when that happened. but she didn’t meet sophia so why would tabitha recognize her? and for that matter we don’t know if her memories of miranda’s life are perfectly complete or if she just remembers some things. if she had ALL of miranda’s memories with perfect recall then you’d expect her to act towards victor the way henry does, and to care about victor just as much as she does ethan and julie.
>>220477106 You fucking idiot, for the talismans to work, they have to be in an enclosed area, so no open doors or windows. Unironically kill yourself. The fact you get to breathe the same oxygen as my pet hamster is an insult to God.
>>220476578 He was constantly doing shit in seasons 1 and 2, they just ran out of ideas for what to do with him in season 3 which is why they killed him off to begin with
>>220477277 time travel is always bad because it creates these shitty loops and paradoxes. then to resolve that shit they need to create parallel universes
>>220477994 memes asides I am curious about miy’s language when he kills people. it’s almost like he is only doing it because he has to, in response to something the townspeople have done. maybe he literally can’t kill unless it’s in response to a “rule” being broken or something like that?
>>220477106 Oh wow I can't believe the writers missed this blunder! I hope someone was fired that. You'd think a competent show would clearly lay out the rules for the talismans in the first episode of the entire show lmao
>>220478372 >don't open the door or any windows or the monsters will get inside >open the door, monsters get inside >retard on /tv/ goes "what the hell is going on"
>>220478505 >nooooooo man in yellow don't sit on my face nooooo don't make me eat your pale teen vag and asshole ahhhhhh noooooo don't squirt your juices into my mouth ahhhhh i can't swallow fast enough it's dribbling down my chin ahhhhh nooooo what do you mean you're going to feed me noooo don't smother me with your boobs ahhhhhhh
>>220477870 Boyd found the talismans in an open space. They worked then. It's so ironic that you'd get worked up over this while being a speedwatcher yourself.
Julie's time travel ability is mitigated and restrained by the MIY, remember when he was laughing at her and mocking her. She wont be able to do anything, like everyone else even though she has superpowers.
>>220478775 That was in the magic mystery cave. The very first episode of the series establishes that the talismans protect an enclosed space only if they're hanging and no one creates an opening for them. this is a core rule of the show.
>>220478812 in the end I think at least one person makes it out and survives even if everyone else dies. I don’t see them wanting a downer nihilistic ending where evil prevails and everybody dies or remains trapped in fromville. could be wrong, but I think the theme isn’t futility but rather never giving up.
>>220479033 I feel like there was an unspoken rule that they had to at least every other episode give us a from monster night scene because you know that's like the entire pitch of this show but now they just don't care
>>220479077 You keep trying and you will succeed. If you don't try you will never succeed. It reminds me of a spider that was stuck in my sink. It kept prodding the walls of the sink for literally hours and kept falling down. I left it there to see what will happen. After some time I saw it outside of the sink. After trying, it found a wall it could climb eventually. Left the lilbro to live.
>>220479096 To be honest, the night scenes aren't that relevant to the plot. They mainly serve as shock horror and rarely advance the story. The daytime scenes where they learn stuff are much more interesting. Shame they rarely do interesting stuff during the daytime either.
>>220479157 The new thing is the yelllowguy now, because he can roam during the day. Which kinda puts the night in the back, dunno why. Lots of people will die in this season before they figure shit out.
The dialogue is so bad. So many short scenes of characters saying the same shit over and over and over again. Every scene is two characters being sad or scared and trying to console each other but no actual interesting character drama just the same drivel all the time.
>>220479348 pretty sure they don't write dialogue, just an outline of the scene for the actors to improv christopher guest style that's why there's so much repetition
>>220479033 We had Sophia being saved by Kenny because she ran outside retardedly after her fake dad died. Err... we also had Elgin and Fatima have a brief conversation at night? So that's at least 2 night scenes technically
>>220479401 i literally can't imagine what it must be like to go through live as a smoking hot red head with a pretty face, big milky tits and a nice ass
>>220478775 1 – The hole in the tree was covered by branches. 2 – There were several of them in that small space. 3 – That was the space Boyd found them, they weren't set up by a human. 4 – In the scene, it even looks like the monster wanted Boyd to find them. The two situations are not slightly comparable, fat yankoid trash.
>>220478505 it's on mgm+ (apparently) and they do explicit nudity (apparently) so i guess it's the from showrunner's choice not to have nudity in this show
>just made 6 pieces of homemade french toast >hot chocolate >redownloaded Seasons 1-3 last night and rewatching until new episode drops Who else here is /comfy/ as fuck?
Is anything ever going to get resolved in this show or is it just another Lost style mystery stack? I'm getting a bit fed up with it. Just on s4e1. It kind of just feels like it a show of moments.
>>220481169 >ok you can have a sexy redhead with milky tits and a nice ass but she must be the embodiment of all evil that the diverse cast team up to beat
>>220481369 We already got some info in season 3 about the monsters and the kids and the reincarnation of two people who have to 'save' them. That shit will get loredumped on us in the final episode so we know roughly what it's about. All the minor mysteries and side quests and really anything happens in Fromtown will never be explained.
>>220481541 I don't mind an open ended mystery, but there isn't enough meat on the bone for you to make interesting logical conclusions. Too much empty space. I would settle for some good clues desu.
>>220478505 something tells me she's one of those women like jessica chastain who look better with clothes on, like her titties seem like they should be huge but they're not
>>220481677 oh yeah totally, I'd hate to see her knockers, I mean come on, they look perfect while covered, why wouldn't they look disgustingly ugly naked? Eww, just imagine
>>220475154 >>220475194 >>220475824 >storywalker rules clearly stated in the book >broken due to a random ass loophole My understanding is now as long as the character hasn't died yet ON SCREEN, she can save them. So if Donna is about to fucking die, Julie can swoop in and save them due to it not happening yet ON SCREEN. Seems like an unnecessary cop out when time travel would've been useful by itself due to finding out information, that she would've probably never shared.
>>220481100 I remember I pissed myself twice in high school. First time was Freshmen year, we were coming home from school and transferring trains. One of my friends said or did something so funny that I literally pissed myself dying. You know that feeling when you laugh so hard, you lose control of your body, everything is in slow motion and your head feels crazy. It was one of those kind of laughs and I couldn't hold it and pissed myself. Luckily I had on dark pants and nobody could see. The other time was my Junior year of high school. I had to piss badly after school let out but I was racing home, for what I have no clue. But I remember I was waiting for the bus, couldn't hold it and just let loose and pissed the fuck out of myself, literally one of the greatest pisses of my life. Thank god it was raining heavy that day, so I just let like 2-3 buses go by, so I could get drenched in the rain so nobody would notice. Those are the only times I can honestly remember pissing myself, besides obviously wetting the bed as a little kid.
>>220481998 I don’t think she’s going to change the past. I think it’s more likely she’s going to learn something about the past that helps them in the present.
>>220482062 maybe she was there when the miy transformed into the redhead and we'll see it again from her perspective and finally get to see those milkers
>>220482106 you mean the rope? she didn’t change that. boyd always had a rope thrown down to him. he didn’t die and then julie had to go back in time and save him, rewriting history.
>>220482229 so you are saying boyd has a rope thrown at him but it's not julie and it's julie at the same time? like julie's cat box of two things are possible at the same time?
>>220481998 The rules haven't really been defined yet. Assuming it's been written semi-competently (big assumption), and based on what miy said when Julie failed to save Jim, it's literally a typical closed loop. She can't change anything that hasn't already been changed. It's nothing to do with what happens on-screen. The easiest example is Buckbeak from Harry Potter. Buckbeak never actually died because they went back to save him. They went back to save him because they thought he had died, but he hadn't (because they went back to save him). Likewise, Julie can save people she thinks have died. But she can't stop someone from dying if they actually died.
>>220483350 the lesbo subplot is such a drain on the show, but they do seem to be immune to bad things, so this might be the answer, turn every woman lesbo and they will be safe.
>>220471152 Why do people here insist on fantasizing about made up stuff like this? She doesn't have big tits, she never has yet everyone here is obsessed.
>>220484229 There is literally a picture attached to the post and you're still just looking reality in the eye and being like nah they actually were fat fr though
Driving in my car a bit before dark Hey I found where I'm gonna park "Can I come in?", I'll do you one better How about you stay in, forever? Little do you know, I've got talismans Imma trap your your spooky smiling pans Immuring these fucks With my trusty truck It seems you're out of luck TRUCK!
>>220484266 I've also seen the aforementioned season of the show in question anon I'm not calling them fat, I'm saying they are well proportioned. A floodlight picture of the actress ain't changing that
>>220483986 >immune to bad things Marielle got put in a nightmare demon coma and tortured for several days, she just inexplicably didn't get any noticeable lasting effects like the other two did. Also she's visibly aged like 10 years since she got there
>>220484363 she is still around and is mostly fine, also kicked her addiction fairly easily, even dismissed her ordeal as le mindrape. can't really give a shit about her.
>>220484427 Her entire character just feels completely pointless. I guess her arrival there was a neat weird moment, and she's useful for nurse stuff when her gf is busy, but that's really it. Very pointless character. There wasn't even that much drama over her being in the coma, her gf didn't care nearly as much as she should have
>>220481677 >>220481901 you are both pornbrained and will be disappointed by literally all tits irl if you don't accept reality real tits are all different shapes and sizes and hers are big and juicy and delicious and she should let me suck on them
MIY stated his favorite part is watching them turn on each other, but in the past he just killed/ate everyone instead. Why bother doing all this mind fuckery and just kill them instead of letting them actually kill each other?
/from/bros do any of you guys use Roku? for the past few weeks I keep getting like, the MGM+ channel advertising From on my home screen. anyone else seeing it?
>>220486529 We only know about the eating. Maybe he just set something in motion that caused them to scatter and get killed at night, then ate them in the morning
>>220479536 Her social media posts are her screaming for attention and validation. She is full of issues. Probably being a ginger was hard, but becoming an actress has given her tools to control the narrative around her.
>>220486261 Trying to slowly ease her in to doing something that will have actual negative consequences. Even if someone did drink the water, nothing would have happened.
>>220486529 remember he was in the town for a while before everyone died. victor thought he was a nice guy. so clearly he does something that causes things to go to shit in the town, or he just shows up right before that happens each time.
>>220471403 >don't forget how Elgin gets tricked into just temporarily kidnapping Fatima You mean helping force her to clone one of those creatures at night while trapped inches away from a hole going directly to the place they sleep. All while saying it's OK fatima the clone is actually gonna save us all. Elgin just fucked up even more by making it personal for boyd. I don't know why boyd wouldn't explain what he just did though. If you knew then why would you want to tell everyone you helped revive one of those creatures anyway?
how do we even know the man in yellow old man form is his true form? maybe that yellow suit was some clothes from a previous cycle dead person he put on? ofr all we know he could be ethan or some more unexpected character several transformations deep
